4 ms·
Sigh... it's one of those articles. Headline claims "scientists" do this, but the quote in the article is: > "As a consumer, I wash all my foods like crazy,”
by ajross 7y ago
Sigh... it's one of those articles. Headline claims "scientists" do this, but the quote in the article is:
> "As a consumer, I wash all my foods like crazy,” says Christine Ogilvie Hendren, executive director of the Center for the Environmental Implications of NanoTechnology at Duke University
So... she's an advocate against this stuff pushing an agenda that it shouldn't be there, not a scientist talking about a finding.
That said: there's no particular reason for TiO2 powder to be in food. It's an inert white pigment, and does nothing but make the processed food (which we already know is bad for you absent any colorings added) more attractive.
But come on folks: this story is sensationalist nonsense. Actual science on this stuff seems broadly unconclusive, and this particular pigment is in very wide deployment across basically the whole world. Any measurable effects are going to be very low significance.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- refurb 7y agoThis is a really bad article. I like how the claim is "a cancer risk can't be ruled out". By definition, anything not tested for cancer risk "can't be ruled out". Maybe the headline should be "BREAKING: You can't prove a negative!"
- tqi 7y agoI've noticed a several Guardian articles pop up on the front page this week with questionable science / outlandish headlines: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20035473 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20035473 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20034411 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20034411 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20026454 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20026454
- weberc2 7y agoSeems like many of these sensationalist articles are coming from the same publication or cluster of publications.
- sterkekoffie 7y agoShe's a scientist with an extensive body of publications in this domain; same with Christine Payne and Sowmya Purushothaman, the other two "scientists voicing concern." I agree that the article would have benefited from more diversity of perspective but it's unfair to characterize these contributors as "advocates pushing their agenda," and it's both inaccurate and disrespectful to use scare quotes when calling them scientists and to imply (if that was your intention) that they do not participate in "real" science. As well, it isn't clear to me why one would read the title "Scientists voice concern about nanoparticles" and expect to read about about a particular research result rather than a survey of the current state of understanding.
- ajross 7y ago> She's a scientist with an extensive body of publications in this domain In the context of that quote, as made explicit by attribution, she's an activist pushing a policy choice. That's not an indictment of her expertise, but it needs to be called out. She doesn't get to both advocate for a position in the text and stand in for "scientists"[1] in an appeal to authority argument in the headline. [1] These are, obviously, not "scare quotes"[2]. The word literally appears in the headline and I'm discussing the fact that it does! [2] Those aren't either. You wrote the words and I'm repeating them with the quotes to indicate that I'm discussing the phrases used in your "argument"[3] [3] Those are.
- sterkekoffie 7y agoIt would seem, by your logic, that it is actually impossible for scientists to voice concern about anything, because once they do so, they can no longer be called scientists, only advocates. If that's the case, then I simply disagree with your logic. If it isn't, and you see some egregious bias-having somewhere in the scientists' statements or qualifications, feel free to point it out. If you can do so without the overt hostility, even better.
- ajross 7y agoYou're still misunderstanding. It's not a criticism of the people quoted, it's a criticism of the journalism that presented the ideas as consensus worries when they're actually pretty niche concerns without a lot of good basis. You can advocate for anything you want, and we can post a link to a screed by the hilariously named "Center for the Environmental Implications of NanoTechnology"[1] and we can discuss that here if you like. But for the Guardian to do that is just editorializing. [1] Still not scare quotes