6 ms·
I'm struggling with the whole "Orwellian" angle, if Uber is going to start keeping jerks from using their service.
by SketchySeaBeast 7y ago
I'm struggling with the whole "Orwellian" angle, if Uber is going to start keeping jerks from using their service.
- daenz 7y agoToday it's Uber's jerks, tomorrow it's people accused of being jerks elsewhere on the internet.
- fwip 7y agoThat doesn't really make any sense. Low-star riders make the drivers' experiences worse. That's why they're low rated.
- daenz 7y agoI'm not arguing against the idea that low-star riders make drivers' experiences worse and that's why they have low ratings. I'm arguing against the idea that a "social metric", which can be changed and expanded (to include, hypothetically, your credit score), should be used to deny access to services, without strong guarantees about the sources and other aspects of that social metric. The Orwellian aspect is when companies start sharing their scores, and when those scores start having clearly highly subjective influences.
- aeternus 7y agoAfter watching some videos of what Uber drivers have to put up with, as well as having a few friends that work in retail, some kind of "social metric" may not be the worst thing. As a society, we put up with a lot of terrible behavior and people get away with it because they don't care about making a scene or situation that is uncomfortable for everyone else. We pay higher prices to deal with these people's behavior: constantly complaining until they get free stuff, abusing return policies, review blackmail, vandalizing state/national parks, cutting lines, etc. You're right though that we need very strong guarantees around the sources and accuracy of such a metric.
- phil21 7y agoI had a very similar reaction 25ish years ago when I found out as a teen credit agencies exist and were somehow not illegal (but employment blacklists are). Don't worry - I was told they are optional, and you only need them for major things like if you getting a new car or house financed. Anyone worried about these things were mocked with the slippery slope "fallacy" typically being the counterargument. Of course scope creep inevitably happened - and now you are effectively locked out of many parts of society if you have a poor credit score. We were told it was outright illegal to use credit scores when hiring people (again, 25 years ago) so our fears were unjustified. Now we're running credit reports on entry level warehouse positions, some volunteer jobs, etc. With every reason to believe it's going to get more pervasive. As these "social rating" systems get more normalized with consumers, I fully expect to see "novel" new uses and data sharing starting to happen.
- quotemstr 7y agoWho gets to decide who counts as a jerk? You? Think of somebody who's a jerk. Would you want that person at Uber deciding whether you should get a ride? This question of "who decides?" is essential. I see snarky response after snarky response that ignores how power and authority corrupt decision-making. I hope we can all agree that the decision to bar someone from participating in important ways in society should not rest on the unsupervised whims of people in Bay Area meeting rooms.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoI believe that it's the drivers setting the score isn't it?
- mlazos 7y agoIt’s pretty obvious who decides who is the jerk, the drivers. If you have an average of like 1 Star, is every single driver you’ve ever ridden with wrong? I think this is fine, they’re not drawing an arbitrary line, they’re saying wow if this person has made drivers rate him this badly then they shouldn’t be using the service. This seems entirely reasonable to me - I’ve ridden with some real assholes and don’t take Pool anymore as a result.
- jakear 7y ago“Jerk” could mean anything though. “Jerk” could be girls that don’t flirt back. Or mothers with small children. Or disabled people needing more time getting in and out of the car.
- anchpop 7y agoAre you aware of any anecdotes of people saying their rating fell when they didn't flirt back or got on crutches or something? (Your point is still valid even if you don't, I'm just interested)
- jakear 7y agoMy Uber rating fell noticeably while I was on crutches for around 6 months, it has since risen. This is in Boston.
- jakear 7y ago“Jerks” can be “people who are disabled and require more time getting in and out of the car”. Being on crutches, for instance, will cause your rating to fall. (At least that was my experience while in Boston)
- dmix 7y agoWell the good thing about a marketplace is that when you act poorly at one business, you can still visit another one. Uber isn't and shouldn't be the only option available to people. The laws that force every company to offer everything to everyone without question are almost always the markets with only one option. All you're left with is a pseudo-market that offers few of the benefits of real private or public markets. A pretend public service with even less accountability and fewer people profiting from the industry.
- AlexandrB 7y ago> Well the good thing about a marketplace is that when you act poorly at one business, you can still visit another one. We’re quickly heading to an Uber/Lyft duopoly. And they use similar ratings systems. Soooooo, I’m not sure what your point is. This isn’t a market, it’s a VC funded takeover of transportation.
- dmix 7y agoRide hailing apps are the only forms of transportation now?
- falcolas 7y agoIt's been documented that drivers have rated riders low for not giving a tip or not leaving a review... Are those really "jerks"?
- wavepruner 7y agoDrivers have no way of knowing if someone will tip/review before they are prompted for a rating. Drivers rate riders immediately after the ride finishes.
- falcolas 7y ago> Whether a cash tip or given through an app, 85 percent of drivers agreed that not tipping was a factor in passengers’ ratings. https://driving-tests.org/confessions-of-an-uber-driver/ https://driving-tests.org/confessions-of-an-uber-driver/ > Uber drivers have long been known to give passengers low ratings if they suspect a passenger is going to give them a low rating. https://www.ridester.com/uber-passengers-ratings-sting/ https://www.ridester.com/uber-passengers-ratings-sting/ So, yes, they don't base it off the actual review (that may be a service other than Uber that I'm recalling), but they'll often base your review off the review they expect you to give them. Seems legit. /s
- wavepruner 7y agoSuccessful, long-time drivers do not waste there time with this pettiness. Nor do they waste time talking to reporters about insignificant issues like this when that time could be better spent actually making money. I've been driving on and off for 5 years now and all us veterans on the Facebook groups laugh at how silly all the constant nitpicking is. As with any rating system, there will be outlying bad raters. That's why it is normal for absolutely no one to have a perfect 5 star. It's really not a bid deal.
- falcolas 7y agoYou’re creating a bit of a “No true Scotsman” fallacy. “No ‘veteran’ driver would rate someone based on tips or their expected rating.” Yet people are being rated on their tips. People are being rated based on their expected ratings of the driver, regardless of their “success” as a driver. It’s a big deal because it locks someone out of a system that has forced out its competition (illegally in some cases; such as in London).