3 ms·
>However, that report shows the pilots left the thrust too high and turned the motor driving MCAS back on after initially switching it off. I really wish the m
by salawat 7y ago
>However, that report shows the pilots left the thrust too high and turned the motor driving MCAS back on after initially switching it off.
I really wish the media wouldn't leave out important context when making statements like this.
If you aren't a pilot or an aviation enthusiast, you'd think leaving the thrust high was a mistake, but an on the fritz AoA sensor means you're in an airspeed unreliable condition, which calls for maintaining appropriate power for the desired flight regime, which in this case was TO/ascent, a regime generally flown at higher power.
https://www.skybrary.aero/index.php/Unreliable_Airspeed_Indications https://www.skybrary.aero/index.php/Unreliable_Airspeed_Indi...
Or, how leaving the airspeed issue unresolved until the more pressing issue, the plane being continually put out of trim, is a triage call akin to what a medical professional would be expected to make in a condition where there were more problems to solve than hands or brains to resolve them.
Or how Boeing intentionally changed the functionality of the console stabilizer trim cutout switches in such a way as to prevent pilots from being able to shut out the flight computer's capability to command trim adjustments with the trim motor, but maintaining the pilots' ability to leverage the trim motor to neutralize trim against aerodynamic load through their trim switches on the yoke.
https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boeing-altered-key-switches-in-737-max-cockpit-limiting-ability-to-shut-off-mcas/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boein...
This is one of those cases where we need the layman to be accurately informed at all costs. There is no room for weasel legal maneuvering that we as a society can afford when this comes to trial. The courts have no authority over physics.
- yread 7y ago> maintaining appropriate power for the desired flight regime, which in this case was TO/ascent, a regime generally flown at higher power. But the memory item calls for 75% N1 and 4deg pitch up. Not leaving it at 94% N1
- salawat 7y agoTrue, but they hadn't even gotten to that stage of the triage yet, and had no explicit documentation or training to make them aware of the counterindication of dealing with airspeed unreliable (by dealing with it actively, or postponing it) followed by stab trim runaway. The important takeaway is that no matter which way you look at it, this "you don't need to know" item absolutely needed to be known since new error cases altered the process of "walking the fault tree" had been substantially. Calling them on the throttle is a bit like blaming a blindfolded man for walking off a cliff with his shoe untied. Yes, the untied shoe may have tripped him up, but the culprit is still pretty damn clear.
- FabHK 7y agoIs the 75% and 4deg pitch for cruise, or for initial climb out from a high altitude airport in mountainous terrain?