4 ms·
In addition to employers wanting competent employees, they are mostly unwilling to train them or pay them. Andecdote time... I have a friend who manages a foo
by alistairSH 7y ago
In addition to employers wanting competent employees, they are mostly unwilling to train them or pay them.
Andecdote time...
I have a friend who manages a food production facility (big factory, think Coca-Cola) and they are always short on skilled welders who can do food-grade work. While the wages look good on paper, the working conditions are spectacularly awful (working inside giant metal tanks that get hot as hell, lots of long hours and weekends, etc). And there is no internal path to get these jobs.
When I ask how an 18 year old gets these jobs, he doesn't have a good answer (beyond "go to trade school"). When I ask why an 18 year old should pick this job over [generic office job], he doesn't have a good answer (beyond "it pays slightly better"). Sorry, nobody is going to pick $25/hour in shit conditions (with the wear and tear on body and lack of job security) over $20/hour in an AC'ed office (it may pay less, but at least you won't be crippled by the time you're 60).
- Balgair 7y ago> In addition to employers wanting competent employees, they are mostly unwilling to train them or pay them. I've seen this SO many times. From very big firms, to ten man shops. No one does any substantive training anymore. They mostly just throw you at the problems and then let you learn on your own (read: Google it). However, in every one of these firms, they tend to be skilled/high-tech. By that, I mean that the firms are doing things that no school would ever teach you how to do. How many HNers know how to properly do an Atterberg test in Oregon? How many of you can get a simulation of a PCB running in pSpice by the end of the day? How many of you can harvest and patch-clamp a neuron from a gerbil this afternoon? But when I talk to these managers and execs, they all complain that they cannot afford to train people. Usually, they state that if they do train the person, then that person will just then go walk off with the training experience and work at another firm. These 'right to work' states act perniciously. At Walmart, such laws heavily favor the employer, but at small highly trained firms, it heavily favors the employee. I wonder what the population stats look like in terms of how 'right to work' laws function towards small and medium sized firms.
- alistairSH 7y agoif they do train the person, then that person will just then go walk off with the training experience and work at another firm. That's the free market at work. If a trained [skilled job] is worth $100k, but you're only willing to pay $90k because "they're new", they should walk across the street. I absolutely hate when self-declared "free market" believers don't understand that there are two sides to every market. And employment is just another market. (not claiming you're making that mistake, but it's one I see frequently when wage discussions come up)
- Balgair 7y agoHaving seen this up close and being a good friend to both the owners and the newbs, the market based approach is non-optimal in this stiuation. People want to be hired and trained, and need to be trained to preform the work. The issue, especially at smaller firms, is that training takes a lot of resources that aren't easy to spare. As such, the year costs and benefits aren't nearly as close. As an extreme and simplified example: The new hire needs to be paid $50k/year. Also, the profit off their labor is $10k/year (firm makes $60k, pays employee $50k). However, training lasts 6 months. So, for half the year, they are not net profitable. That means that they are net negative their first year (0.5 X $60k = $30k lost in 6 months, add that to $50k paid out and you get $80k as the total 'cost' of the newbie at year's end. You end up at -$20k for the year for the newbie). So, to make back the cost of training this newbie, you would need for that employee to work for you for two more years (2 years X $10k/year profit = $20k. The training cost was -$20k). Then you would be net neutral. Also, not only is the new hire not 'pulling their weight', but they also take time and energy away from other employees. To add to this, the newbie can just walk out and get hired somewhere else at any time. If that were to occur, then you really have to eat the costs of the traning and will not see any investment come back. In fact, it is likely to be going to help out a competitor. Now, the above is an extreme example, of course. But some form of this calculus is occuring at smaller firms. Perhaps it's only six weeks of training that occurs. Perhaps they make much more profit off of the employees. Perhaps your business is growing fast and your are getting more efficient. Still, there is a significant cost to training newbies, one that many firms are loathe to pay out. Now, economists have been talking about these issues for a LONG time. This kind of 'capital' investment mechanism is well studied, and , yes, a market is a very good way of sussing these things out. However, we also know that markets are rational, and humans in a market are far from rational. These 'sunk cost' fallacies are very painful to humans. I suspect that they are very painful when it comes to training. You work with a person for weeks to months, watch them grow and learn, get to know them well, you put time and effort into them and come to care about them. Then the market comes in and takes all that emotional investment away, because 'prices'. It's not easy and it is not rational, it becomes (in some degree) personal. So, yes, the employment market is a just like any other market. But training is more than that to us humans. That kind of investment is not something that can always be priced.
- cobbzilla 7y agoskilled pipe welders can make a lot more than $25/hr, more than double that in most urban markets.
- alistairSH 7y agoSorry, should have been clear - the numbers were made up. But, the point still stands - the wages are not high enough to entice workers out of their A/C'ed offices.
- cobbzilla 7y agoone can raise a family in modest comfort at $50+/hour. much moreso than at $25 anyway. Many trades are in high demand everywhere now, the “enticement” comes from necessity in many cases.