5 ms·
Oh great, a private company promising to store my home address and other sensitive personal details in a database. That surely won't get breached at all, ever,
by vorpalhex 7y ago
Oh great, a private company promising to store my home address and other sensitive personal details in a database. That surely won't get breached at all, ever, in any way, due to terrible malfeasance of even the most basic security principles.
Oh, and combined with lobbying cities to force adoption?
Realistically, how do we prevent every blockhead with an unsecured database from hoovering up personal information? Can we start instituting major fines and the requirement to carry liability insurance or something?
- astura 7y agoI can't read TFA because it's paywalled, so I don't know if it talks about the information saved, but they don't need your home address, ID number and issuer is all they need to store as far as PII goes and you don't even have to store those directly - you can encrypt them like a password.
- roywiggins 7y agoYou can brute force an ID number a lot easier than a good password.
- NoInputSignal 7y agoI think OP was asking: even though there are best practices to follow when storing PII, how can we trust every private entity that stores our PII to be using those best practices?
- droithomme 7y agoThe article states that they store in their database your "name, gender, date of birth, zip code, and photo", but currently they don't store your address or id number. The information stored though is certainly sufficient to find your street address and a great deal of other information in almost all cases since a full legal name + DoB + zip code match is nearly always a unique identifier. Storing the id photo is fun and no doubt useful for further tracking of the patron using things such as the cameras on the table kiosks. Also the photo has value for sale to other interested parties.
- imgabe 7y agoWe can't, which is why stopping people from collecting information is the wrong place to prevent bad actors. Your address is not a secret. If you own a home, it is necessarily a matter of public record. If you ever want to have anything delivered to you, you necessarily have to share it. If having your address in a database is a problem for you, you're going to have to learn subsistence farming and move completely off the grid, because you're not really going to be able to function in modern society.
- CPLX 7y agoHow would you feel about having your name, address, and photograph in a database of people who frequently visit bars catering to the gay community? Would you change your answer if you lived in Alabama, or on a military base?
- imgabe 7y agoI wouldn't care. Straight people go to gay bars. I've gone to several on a few different occasions, despite being straight. I doubt I would want to associate with anyone who would care. I'm confident that I could find people who wouldn't even think to check such a database even in gasp Alabama or on a military base. Just because someone doesn't live in one of the five approved liberal cities doesn't mean they're automatically a bigoted jerk.
- liability 7y ago> "Just because someone doesn't live in one of the five approved liberal cities doesn't mean they're automatically a bigoted jerk." And just because somebody does live in a liberal city doesn't mean they don't have legitimate reasons to desire privacy.
- imgabe 7y agoKnowledge of your address is not a violation of privacy. I assume you never order take out food or receive mail?
- _jal 7y agoI do think liability insurance is a good idea in theory; in practice, it will shut down "little people" projects and will likely only effect the worst of the worst. (Which is not nothing, but not enough.) Mroe generally, the answer is "everything you can think of". People are trying to pull the world in a direction you don't like, so pull it in a different direction. Poison their data. Explain why they're awful to everyone you can. Talk to your local ABC authority before these jerks get there and explain why this is terrible. Try to solve the whatever actualy "problem" there is here in a less intrusive way. Whatever else you can think of that is legal. You don't have to ask for permission to fight back. For my part, I will not go to establishments that scan my ID. I'll show it to you for legal compliance reasons, but you don't get to record it. If your house rules say otherwise, that's fine, I'll spend my money in some other house.
- village-idiot 7y agoI do the latter implicitly. Any place that’s crowded enough to have ID scanners sounds like my own personal hell.
- bilbo0s 7y agoAgree wholeheartedly. Even if you are a social butterfly, use your head. That place has decided that they need ID scanners. Just imagine the things that have happened that made that necessary.
- CamperBob2 7y agoJust imagine the things that have happened that made that necessary. I'm imagining visits from pushy ID-scanner salesmen, stopping by the bar to drum up some business while on their way to meet with legislators.
- liability 7y agoThe possibility of fines, even large ones, is ultimately just considered a cost of doing business. If you really want to stop this sort of behavior we'll need a streamlined process for piercing the veil and criminally prosecuting both executives and engineers, with very serious (but fully deserved) setencing guidelines.
- andrewaylett 7y agoThis is one of the kinds of behaviour that the GDPR is designed to protect against.
- hindsightbias 7y agoWe’re all one GDPR violation from bankruptcy. Time to put some EU risk takers and ambulance chasing lawyers in Sacramento together for freedom. Would make a great startup.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y ago> Realistically, how do we prevent every blockhead with an unsecured database from hoovering up personal information? GDPR. You need to take GDPR, translate it to your local language without removing any clauses, maybe add some liability for processors too, and get that implemented as a law.