6 ms·
Unfortunately the global machine only works well if the parts are working together for the greater good in the first place, which is not a given.
by fastball 7y ago
Unfortunately the global machine only works well if the parts are working together for the greater good in the first place, which is not a given.
- simonh 7y agoOne country benefiting more from trade than another isn't the same thing as the other country being worse off because of the trade. They're just not as much better off as they could have been. The goal of these disputes should be to reach a more equitable trading arrangement, not to stop or restrict trade that is 'harming' countries[1]. The Idea that the US is 'losing' due to the trade deficit and that reducing trade with China will benefit America is utter tosh and even the administration's own trade advisers and negotiators are saying so (a bit more politely). [1] There are some narrow cases where trade can be harmful, or where national interest could legitimately be served by restricting trade, but that excuse is being used vastly disproportionately in the current disputes.
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoThere is nothing inequitable in the current trade arrangements that were set by the West. The US and the West have benefited massively, and still are. That line is just spin repeated again and again until people accept it without questions. The actual issue for the US is the rise of China as a global power that does not answer to them.
- simonh 7y agoBy and large you're mostly right. There are some inequities in the way China treats foreign firms though. Completely blocking all the main US web technology firms for example. However I don't think the harm being done to the US economy by the trade war is worth the benefits to be gained, even though there may be some benefits.
- NotPaidToPost 7y ago> Completely blocking all the main US web technology firms for example That's a question of being willing to comply with Chinese contents-control requirements rather than trade per se. And if they comply they face a huge public opinion backlash in the US... At the same time, it is understandable that a developing country try to develop its own companies rather than handed its market to US companies... Level playing field and all that ;)
- fastball 7y agoChina literally steals tech from US businesses, mass produces it, and then undercuts the US companies that they stole the tech from in the US market. Get outta here with your "China can do nothing wrong".
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoNot literally "steals"... It's not possible to "literally steals" tech.
- fastball 7y agoWhat else would you call sending in people to illicitly copy data and designs under false pretenses?
- pytester 7y ago>The Idea that the US is 'losing' due to the trade deficit and that reducing trade with China will benefit America is utter tosh and even the administration's own trade advisers and negotiators are saying so (a bit more politely). The problem isn't so much the deficit as it is the way the US has been seduced into relying upon the Chinese industrial machine. The US industrial base has been depleting for decades. This presents a serious systemic risk - the US relies more and more on Chinese industry which can (and probably will, at some point) be cut off. This will result in massive inflation. In (neoclassical) theory getting cut off isn't a problem because the market will simply bring all of that industry back to the United States. In practice, the flow of goods can be cut off overnight but an industrial base on a par with the pearl river delta would take at least two decades to build.
- oblio 7y agoThe "depleting" US industrial base is producing 2x what it was producing in 1990: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/INDPRO https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/INDPRO :) Which is pretty good growth, all things considered. Mini-rant, feel free to ignore: The alternative perspective which assumes total US industrial domination up to the present day (MAGA/Trump) is quite irrational considering world history: the US had almost no real industrial competition post-WW2 when all the other industrialized countries were either: * shattered by wars in their homelands * or completely cut-off from the rest of the world for 50 years... So the industrial prowess of the US 1950 - 1970 (relative to the rest of the world) isn't coming back, now we're just headed for a normal equilibrium. One in which the US is still doing quite well from an industrial point of view.
- simonh 7y agoProduction is up, but jobs are down to about half as much as a proportion of the population, and by about a third in real terms. But then unemployment is quite low right now and there are plenty of un-filled jobs. Pay for low wage earners has seen some encouraging gains over the last few years. It's not clear the US actually needs a huge boost in manufacturing jobs. Historically, attempts to preserve or boost jobs artificially through trade manipulations have had limited success at massively disproportionate costs. Anyway in absolute terms manufacturing jobs aren't exactly low, it's at about the same level as in 1949.
- fastball 7y agoChina literally steals IP from US businesses and uses the fact that they had no R&D costs and cheaper production to then sell those "stolen" products back to the US, undercutting the US businesses that invented the IP. This is not a "neutral" behavior. And this is different from the past when "every country stole ideas" because in those other instances the "thief countries" weren't generally trading those products with their target. It's fine to steal ideas if you use it to make your own country better. It's not fine to steal things which you then use to undercut the people you stole from.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y ago> if the parts are working together for the greater good No, it also works surprisingly well if everyone is acting rationally but purely optimizing for self-interest.
- stareatgoats 7y agoThe question is if it works well in all relevant aspects and not only some. I believe a fair investigation would reveal a little of both well and bad to everyone except the most die-hard ideological laissez-faire purist. One such relevant negative aspect of all-out competition is that trade wars between superpowers backed by massive nuclear arsenals poses not only a risk to the world economy but also to our survival as a civilization if not species. Working together for the common good seems indeed preferable in this case.