17 ms·
China ready to hit back at U.S. with rare earths
- Leary 7y agoPerhaps this will become news when it actually happens
- killjoywashere 7y agoProbably enough news to boost the stock of the Mountain Pass mine (1) though. And there's plenty of rare earths around. It wouldn't be all bad if they were mined in first-world countries that are willing and able to regulate in a way that forces cleaner production methods. (1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mountain_Pass_rare_earth_mine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mountain_Pass_rare_earth_mine
- scarejunba 7y agoMountain Pass is mostly owned by Shenghe Holding Co. anyway. What an interesting turn of events.
- killjoywashere 7y agoInteresting, how do you know it's majority owned by Shenghe? Are the other investors shells for Shenghe?
- scarejunba 7y agoNo, I misremembered an old fact. It's not majotiyu owned by Shenghe
- Animats 7y ago"Leshan Shenghe Rare Earth Co. Ltd., a Rare Earth company in China, holds a non-voting minority interest in the company." - company website.
- varshithr 7y agoThis is bad for the whole world and reduces the efficiency of the global machine. Now countries have to explore more expensive mines to make up for the demand which could have easily been avoided. It feels like someone is dialing back the productivity of the entire world.
- fastball 7y agoUnfortunately the global machine only works well if the parts are working together for the greater good in the first place, which is not a given.
- simonh 7y agoOne country benefiting more from trade than another isn't the same thing as the other country being worse off because of the trade. They're just not as much better off as they could have been. The goal of these disputes should be to reach a more equitable trading arrangement, not to stop or restrict trade that is 'harming' countries[1]. The Idea that the US is 'losing' due to the trade deficit and that reducing trade with China will benefit America is utter tosh and even the administration's own trade advisers and negotiators are saying so (a bit more politely). [1] There are some narrow cases where trade can be harmful, or where national interest could legitimately be served by restricting trade, but that excuse is being used vastly disproportionately in the current disputes.
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoThere is nothing inequitable in the current trade arrangements that were set by the West. The US and the West have benefited massively, and still are. That line is just spin repeated again and again until people accept it without questions. The actual issue for the US is the rise of China as a global power that does not answer to them.
- simonh 7y agoBy and large you're mostly right. There are some inequities in the way China treats foreign firms though. Completely blocking all the main US web technology firms for example. However I don't think the harm being done to the US economy by the trade war is worth the benefits to be gained, even though there may be some benefits.
- holoduke 7y agoIt might in fact decrease pollution. Western powers will have to open up local national mines (those rare earths aren't so rare as people think). With tougher regulations regarding environment. At a significant cost of course.
- curiousgal 7y agoThe current U.S. administration is nothing but outright hostile against the environment. Those regulations will be laxed and nothing good will come out of this.
- programmarchy 7y agoDo you think Chinese mines would pollute less than US mines? How many environmental activists do you think exist in China?
- pastullo 7y agoThat's a fair point. I guess a mine like Mountain Pass in California would still be a much cleaner site than a chinese mine, even though the EPA is now a clown agency basically. Anyone can confirm this?
- killjoywashere 7y agoHank Paulson indicated in his book, "Dealing with China" that there is actually a respectable current of environmentalism in China, anchored in the Buddist and Confuscian past.
- 08-15 7y agoIt's nearly impossible to mine lanthanides in the west. The problem is that they are invariably associated with thorium, and thorium has been declared (in 1980 or thereabouts) to be a source material for nuclear explosives, even though it really isn't. Nobody wants to deal with the regulations around that, so all the lanthanide mines and refineries closed.
- AFascistWorld 7y agoChina should be careful here, if this does not work then they are pretty much done for, although the CCP can claim mental victory as usual as they've been propagating it as the silver bullet.
- spongepoc 7y agoTrump's shutdown of Huawei is a tactical blinder. I can see no move China can make in response that won't end up harming them more than it will the US. China's mercantilist trade policy of the past 40 years is coming back to bite them, just like it did in the 19th century.
- koffiezet 7y agoWhile the US is a major market, but it's not the only-one. Isolation policies do not work in a globalised economy, China isn't trying to isolate itself, the US is. If the US pulls this sort of erratic crap with one of its major trade partners, others will go look for alternatives too. Yes this will hurt China, but I think you underestimate how hard this would hit the US. This is the next economic crisis in the making, and at least some people in the US government seem to realise this, since the best solution for boosting the economy is going to war. Hello Iran? This is not China that is at fault, it's the US that's being a little cry-baby.
- AFascistWorld 7y agoSo exactly how is China going to ban export to the US specifically? The US isn't even it's big client.
- toddh 7y agoRemember Big Cotton during the US Civil War? The south thought england would take the south's side because so much of their economy was based on southern cotton. It didn't work. The south didn't appreciate england's disgust with slavery. England developed other suppliers and found replacements. Nobody is ever quite as special as they think they are. This goes for all sides.
- dahacker 7y agoI think the US has a large strategic reserves for the rare earth for a year or two. But the rare earth is not just mineral, it is a little link of the whole supply. For now, the supply chain is totally controlled by Chinese companies. I think the cut from China will cause the rising of many key products' price in the US.
- bArray 7y agoFirstly, I don't know what they expect to achieve with these threats. I think the US has shown so far that it's not going to easily bend to such threats, this was a bad move on their part. Maybe they knew this, hence using the media to broadcast this message. Still, this very much sounds like escalation talk rather than de-escalation. Secondly, these "rare earths" aren't actually rare, most mines were simply shut down because they weren't competitive with China. The Chinese deliberately drove the price of various materials into the ground in order to gain a monopoly (a security risk I think the West should have seen coming). A local example of this was Sheffield steel. Thirdly, if the cost of such materials was to rise significantly, hopefully it would have the affect of removing planned obsolescence being built into products. A mobile for twice the price might make people hold onto their mobile devices a little longer before upgrading, for example. Hopefully we can also get modular devices popular again with planned upgrade paths, rather than the glued-together mess we currently deliver.
- Blackstone4 7y agoIt's not just about threatening the US, it's about bolstering the Chinese moral across the nation, building a belief that China is a resilient underdog and the world is against it but it will fight back.
- NotPaidToPost 7y ago> China is a resilient underdog and the world is against it but it will fight back. Which not inaccurate.
- ptah 7y agothat's exactly what the US propaganda also claims
- _iyig 7y ago>China is a resilient underdog and the world is against it but it will fight back U.S. propaganda is the mostly the opposite of this. We’re supposed to be an invincible freedom juggernaut who the whole world loves, including the poor, oppressed people of Iran/North Korea who generally love America [actually true in Iran, from what Persian friends tell me] and just want some drone-delivered democracy. The reality is of course somewhat different.
- tomohawk 7y agoPrevious administrations tried to appease the CCP, hoping to cajole them into at least a moderate stance on human rights, etc. But the CCP is not a live and let live sort of organization, and merely took advantage of these policies to further their interests and wage a one sided trade war.
- ksec 7y ago>Previous administrations tried to appease the CCP Somehow this reminds me of the line in the movie Darkest Hour [1] ; When will the lesson be learned? When will the lesson be learned? How many more dictators must be wooed, appeased - good God, given immense privileges - before we learn? You cannot reason with a tiger when your head is in its mouth. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJ5sjFf4w1k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJ5sjFf4w1k
- newnewpdro 7y agoIsn't this the real reason the US went into Afghanistan? https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-afghanistan-minerals/trump-ghani-agree-u-s-can-help-develop-afghanistans-rare-earth-minerals-idUSKCN1BX06G https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-afghanistan-minerals/...
- baybal2 7y agoI'm surprised why people still talk rare earth, and not tantalum. Tantalum is the real jugular of electronics industry. You should also note that out of all companies, US went to pressure Panasonic — world's biggest maker of advanced capacitors. That alone hit Huawei way way more than ban on cellphone socs and mosfets. You can run away from SoC ban on biggest supplier, mosfet ban by switching to domestic makers, but high spec capacitors... they are a real kill switch.
- stunt 7y agoYou can't push a country to a corner and expect them to do nothing. There are always consequences. Sometimes smart and sometimes stupid.
- stunt 7y agoLooking into history, Stable China normally translates to stable East Asia, and developing China also brings development to East Asia. I don't think we are heading in the right direction but let's assume politicians know what they are doing. (Which often turns to be a wrong assumption and almost always they are safe from the consequences)
- rasz 7y agoThis is fantastic news, now all Trump has to do is double down and put a huge tariff on _any_ product containing rare earth metals extracted specifically in China.
- souprock 7y agoThe USA has sources. Besides the natural ones, we also have coal ash and spent nuclear fuel rods.