3 ms·
I don't know what "a community driven project" means because it doesn't use technical terms. The established technical concepts are stakeholders, consensus, and
by brudgers 7y ago
I don't know what "a community driven project" means because it doesn't use technical terms. The established technical concepts are stakeholders, consensus, and standardization. Go has clearly delineated stakeholders. These are few relative to Go's broader user base. Not being stakeholders, the broader user base is excluded from Go's consensus process. Go's stakeholders do not appear to value standardization of the language.
None of this is inherently bad or good.
- hu3 7y ago> Go's stakeholders do not appear to value standardization of the language This seems rather misinformed. Go has a spec https://golang.org/ref/spec https://golang.org/ref/spec and at least 2 alternative compilers in the form of gccgo and GopherJS. I'd love to hear where do you base the notion that Go's stakeholders do not appear to value standardization of the language.
- brudgers 7y agoSorry for not being clear. I used "standardization" in its established technical sense. In general technical use, standards and specifications are different. Standards are technical documents published by an independent standards organization. For example ISO in the case of the C programming language and ECMA in the case of ECMAscript (i.e. Javascript). Standards (in conventional use) have formal processes for establishing stakeholders, submitting proposed changes, acting on proposed changes, and publishing changes to the standard. Formal processes are not an inherent property of specifications. The Go specification could change in surprising ways tonight. Though it probably won't. The process for changing the Go specification can also change. Specifications are short lived. Standards are 'forever'. Fortran 77 is still Fortran 77 because of X3.9-1978. It is common for specifications to incorporate standards by reference. For example a specification might include "the program should generate valid XHTML 1.1." The standards body W3C provides a process for determining conformance with the standard https://validator.w3.org/ https://validator.w3.org/. T