3 ms·
> In a society increasingly obsessed with credentials, being genetically engineered is like having an Ivy-League M.B.A.: It is a marker of status that makes a c
by neilv 7y ago
> In a society increasingly obsessed with credentials, being genetically engineered is like having an Ivy-League M.B.A.: It is a marker of status that makes a candidate a safe bet for hiring, rather than an indicator of actual competence.
Not specific to fancy MBA programs, but sometimes credentials means more than a safe bet, but also a fraternity or cabal.
Imagine that, by default, there's a level playing field for everyone, but a subgroup of people collude to trade favors amongst themselves. That group will have an advantage over everyone outside the group who are playing by the egalitarian rules.
- RhysU 7y agoImagine that, by default, there's a level playing field for everyone, but a subgroup of people share some common background and therefore they can form trusted connections amongst themselves at lower cost vs the overhead to establish such connections between any two parties who don't know each other from Adam. I claim this not nefarious situation is indistinguishable from your sinister finger pointing.
- neilv 7y agoHow do you mean "trust"? Possibilities include: 1. Trust that the person is capable at particular things. (This you might get from credentials, which perhaps also defines a group, and accomplishments.) 2. Trust that the person is truthful with you, and will honor agreements with you. (This you might get from their reputation within your network/group.) 3. Trust that the person will give preferential treatment to you/group, and that they do this because there is mutual advantage to a subgroup doing that, separate from trust in ability and honesty. (Maybe sometimes this is called loyalty to the group, though you might say you trust in their loyalty. Or maybe it's merely understood.) I'm pretty sure I've seen #3 happen in business/opportunities, read about it in news, and heard people talk firsthand about it, in ways not always covered by #1 and #2.