4 ms·
Marketing has a light side and a dark side. Light side: Closing the loop between what the customer wants, what their actual problems are, and what engineering
by Gibbon1 7y ago
Marketing has a light side and a dark side.
Light side: Closing the loop between what the customer wants, what their actual problems are, and what engineering and manufacturing can deliver.
Darkside: Ladies you need to use our spray or else your hoo-haw will stink.
- munk-a 7y agoThe light side is of so little value that I think we should just throw it out with the bathwater and kill this modern experiment in advertising. Our society is paying huge costs to support this industry in terms of wealth, novel innovations, productivity and sanity. It's terrible.
- jimktrains2 7y ago> The light side is of so little value that I think we should just throw it out with the bathwater and kill this modern experiment in advertising. I don't think that's true at all. Where else would you learn about new services or products? Here are some examples from a 2010 model railroader. https://photos.app.goo.gl/RvRzECgs7MaTo7tP8 https://photos.app.goo.gl/RvRzECgs7MaTo7tP8 Some, especially the Kato model Amtrak one, have some aspects of an aspirational ad, but I don't know if I'd condem them as such. They usually, as the Kato one has, information about the specific items that are now available and often some "ambiance" information that many hobbiests, especially people new to the hobby like to look at. I don't mind ads like these as they're not designed to make you feel as though you need to purchase something to be better and they're not in a public space. They're they're to matter-of-factly says a service or product is available. I could also show you the local pennysaver or Craigslist. All of those are also add, but they're not the "aspirational" kind. They're more matter-of-factly that someone is selling so (used) item, or provides some kind of service, or that there is a garage or estate sale at such-and-such address. How else would this information be made redily and easily available?
- dwaltrip 7y agoHumans learned about new things for thousands of years without the modern of advertisements. I have no fear that the news of useful and interesting products will spread just fine even if advertising is massively reduced.
- jimktrains2 7y agoLet me rephrase your response. > Humans learned about new things for thousands of years without the modern of technology. > I have no fear that the news of useful and interesting information will spread just fine even if technology is massively reduced. Sure, we don't need ads the same way we don't need computers. I however like being able to learn about things outside my physical filter bubble and immensely enjoy my used tools and electronics (along with the massive coat savings) I've bought from ads on Craigslist.
- dwaltrip 7y agoYou would have been able to find those same tools and electronics, you may have had to just spend a few minutes browsing some sort of catalog. The lack of advertisements wouldn't cause any serious difficulties.
- jasode 7y ago>You would have been able to find those same tools and electronics, you may have had to just spend a few minutes browsing some sort of catalog. You may have read the gp's comment too quickly. The context was used tools and electronics from Craigslist ads. The "used" would be pre-owned and less expensive, and "Craigslist" presumably means buying from a local seller. Catalogs for tools and electronics are typically new items that are national in scope instead of local. The Craigslist advertisements made him _aware_ of a local seller selling a used tool that he wanted. What would be the non-advertising way to accomplish that same goal? Possibly driving to flea markets or swap meets every week? But the sellers with their wares on display are themselves a form of advertising. It's also an incredibly inefficient use of time to repeatedly drive to a location and walk away empty-handed compared to seeing a relevant Craigslist ad. >some sort of catalog. The lack of advertisements wouldn't cause any serious difficulties. Fyi in case you were unaware... Many retailers' catalogs are created with ad sponsorships to offset the cost of printing, mailing, etc.
- jodrellblank 7y agoWhy would I want to learn about new services or products? Or more directly to the point, why would I want to let /you/ decide which services and products I learn about, when, where, and how often? When that is a) more in your interest than mine, and b) inevitably going to turn into a "cover every surface and channel into advertising as you try to shout loudest for my attention in competition with every other vendor of every product and service in the world".
- jasode 7y ago>Why would I want to learn about new services or products? I think you missed the context of gp's comment. His example of ads was from a hobby enthusiast's magazine such as Model Railroader.[1] Many readers buy hobby magazines in part for the ads. Yes, there are feature stories but the ads themselves are also informative of new products the readers want to learn about. So to directly answer your question of "why would I want to learn about new services or products?" -- it's because that desire for ads was implicit in your decision to buy a hobby-oriented magazine. (The "I" and "you" is not you specifically but a rhetorical placeholder for the generalized magazine buyer.) Another example of some people expressing a desire for ads is buying the Sunday edition of their local newspaper. (Many readers won't buy the Monday-to-Saturday editions but they'll go out of their way to buy the Sunday copy that's has the ad inserts.) They didn't buy it for the news articles written by journalists; they bought it for the stores' ads to see what's on sale and for the coupons. An opposite example of buying a magazine because it does not have ads would be something like Consumer Reports. [1] https://mrr.trains.com/magazine https://mrr.trains.com/magazine
- kelnos 7y agoI'd very much agree. I don't want people to preemptively try to solve my problems for me. If I have a problem that I've actively decided I want to solve, and have prioritized finding a solution, I'll seek out products to solve it. I don't care to randomly run across an ad for something that I could use, but haven't actively decided that I want to seek out and potentially purchase. For this reason I block ads in every way that I can, no matter how "light-side" they might be.
- JohnFen 7y ago> Light side: Closing the loop between what the customer wants, what their actual problems are, and what engineering and manufacturing can deliver. Marketing seems to have given up on that sort of effort years ago.
- rigorman 7y ago>>Light side: Closing the loop between what the customer wants, what their actual problems are, and what engineering and manufacturing can deliver. >Marketing seems to have given up on that sort of effort years ago. Marketing hasn't, but companies' hiring and organizational structure decisions have - especially tech companies. As long as the only marketing personel a company hires are advertising personel, given authority and responsibility for advertising only, the loop can't be closed. In tech, programmers are the "engineering and manufacturing", but they tend not to want to be told what consumers want by the marketing team (who, if hired and authorized properly, would be doing rigorous independent research and data analysis using data from that research, user data, and bought research, to come by those insights...)
- JohnFen 7y ago> In tech, programmers are the "engineering and manufacturing", but they tend not to want to be told what consumers want by the marketing team This is true. In fact, I'm currently engaged in a bit of a battle over this very thing at my current employer (I'm a software dev). They're hiring a brand new marketing team, but all they've been hiring are salespeople, and I've been pushing them to be sure to include someone who will do actual market research that we devs can use to inform product design.
- Gibbon1 7y agoThat is a good thing to push for because while they overlap Marketing != Sales. A good marketing person is absolutely worth it.
- dTal 7y agoI don't think the "light side" exists. Advertising is fundamentally about convincing the consumer to buy your product, when they otherwise wouldn't have. That goes regardless of whether it's good for them. Sure, it might be good for them, but that's basically irrelevant. If you're giving someone an unbiased opinion about a product or service, that's not advertising - it's a review. At its core, marketing is all about creating information asymmetry. You're not informing the customer, you're persuading them. They're opposites.