2 ms·
My chem department prided itself in the fact that it's core courses and grading system hasn't been touched since around 1995, when they built the current online
by asdff 7y ago
My chem department prided itself in the fact that it's core courses and grading system hasn't been touched since around 1995, when they built the current online lab submission website. "You would have gotten the same grade two decades ago," they promised.
Once you were handed the exams, it was obvious why this was the case. They were hard as shit, class averages would hover around 55%, curved to a C even.
We would later be shown the averages of other sections, lecturers, and years, and they would never sway more than 2-3% off the median score despite different sections, professors, decades even. The only constant maintaining this consistency was the content and pace of the lectures and exams, and the grading scale. Despite all the intergenerational turmoil and educational upheaval debated over the past 25 years, here was the chemistry department throwing perfect darts.
Schools need to decide how rigorous they should be, establish a very clear grading system that tests that rigor, and stick with it for decades.
- jjoonathan 7y agoIf you develop a rigorous, reliable assessment for a rigorous, reliable course then the very last thing you should want is to brand its scores in a way that invites unfavorable comparisons to degree mill rubber stamp "A"s by people who don't know or can't be bothered, yet this is exactly what you do by calling these grades, fitting them to the ABC scale, putting them on report cards, and weighing them into GPAs. It's madness. Such an assessment would have much more value as a standardized test, entrance exam, etc. Yes, those are much harder to develop, but that's the nature of the beast. If you want to facilitate inter-institution comparisons you need to develop inter-institution standards. There's an orthogonal issue here in assessing the assessment. Imagine a terrible test, one with no meaningful relationship between questions and answers. The scores will follow a very reliable, consistent bell curve with very reliable, consistent statistics. So we can't actually take that as an indication of a good test, even if the best possible test would also behave that way.