4 ms·
> 20 years ago was essentially a zero point for the statistic they cite. It was less than 5 gigawatts, anyway. It grew by over 100 times in that 20 years, and i
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> 20 years ago was essentially a zero point for the statistic they cite. It was less than 5 gigawatts, anyway. It grew by over 100 times in that 20 years, and it will be "unprecedented" to grow by 5 times in the next 20?
Do you expect the growth rate of Google over the next 20 years will be the same as it was between 1999 and today?
As things mature you don't get the same level of exponential growth. Meanwhile the subsidies for solar are being reduced etc.
And your chart is installed capacity, not panel production capacity. The growth in panel production capacity is lower than that visual implies.
But let's suppose we could replace nuclear with solar. That doesn't really work because solar can't produce at night and adding the requirement of batteries would make the demand for daytime-only solar generation fall off significantly, but suppose we could do it. That's still not what we need -- we need the expanding solar capacity to replace coal. Every GW of nuclear it would have to replace is one more GW of coal that stays online.
- andrekandre 7y ago> That doesn't really work because solar can't produce at night photovoltaic no, molten salt yes https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crescent_Dunes_Solar_Energy_Project https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crescent_Dunes_Solar_Energy_... btw, driving by them at daytime is pretty weird... the collectors look literally like close-up stars floating above the surface
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoSure, and so does hydro and geothermal and biomass. But people are interested in photovoltaics because they're cost-competitive (during the day at least).
- aeternus 7y agoAre those actually more environment-friendly than nuclear? Seems like those would take up lots of land area and easily fry and possibly blind animals, especially birds that get too close. They do look cool though.
- petre 7y agoDepends on a case by case basis. You'd need a desert, the South of Spain, Greece or Texas. Just like geothermal, it's very location specific, whereas one could deploy a nuclear reactor on the Moon or Mars.
- hutzlibu 7y agoMaybe a bit nitpicking, but solar would even work better on moon and mars due to the lack of atmosphere. But yes, here on earth it is very location specific.
- gwbas1c 7y agoDon't forget that part of moving away from carbon is replacing oil and gas heat with heat pumps (or resistive heat.) And furthermore, heating is needed when days are the shortest. We aren't going to heat our homes with solar power.
- epistasis 7y agoThere have been some efforts to make residential geothermal heat pumps price competitive in many markets. In which case, winter insolation with clouds may actually be enough to heat houses. I would guess that we'll see far more thermal storage (refrigerators, water heaters, etc...) in households as appliances get smarter.
- petre 7y agoThey won't be just because you have to drill a borehole, or two, or lots of ditches >6ft deep.
- gwbas1c 7y agoI don't understand the downvotes. That's why I went with air-based heat pumps instead of geothermal. Everyone I spoke with told me that it was very risky, cost-wise, to install where I live. Granted, geothermal might be more affordable in other geologies.
- jessaustin 7y agoWas this reply intended to go here? I made no predictions. I complained about the word "unprecedented". Are you holding IEA to the same standard you're attempting to apply here? ISTM you've steelmanned their deception to the point that it no longer resembles TFA. They didn't include any of this sophistry. Have all the factories that got us to this level of (obviously) installed capacity burned down recently? Have the investors who invested in them and the engineers who built them all died? OK, I'll make a prediction. Solar capacity will rise to 100% of today's total capacity, and it still won't displace lots of other energy sources. Why? Because when power is cheaper and has fewer negative externalities, we'll use more of it.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> I complained about the word "unprecedented". If you want to be a stickler, what that actually means is that it has never happened before. Have we ever installed ~2500 GW of new photovoltaic generation capacity over a twenty year period? Of any individual generation method? > Have all the factories that got us to this level of (obviously) installed capacity burned down recently? Have the investors who invested in them and the engineers who built them all died? It's not just a question of supply. It's also a question of demand. Subsidizing five times as much capacity would require five time as much government money, which may not be available. If the subsidies end, the demand curve takes a hit. In addition to that, the fact that solar only generates during the day hasn't yet become an issue because the daytime demand is higher, so solar can currently be efficiently used to satisfy the demand differential between day and night. But once there is enough solar generating capacity to satisfy the full differential, that efficiency ends and you start having to deal with expensive energy storage or paying capital and maintenance for alternative generation which is idle and unproductive half the day, effectively requiring the cost of solar to fall lower than the alternative's fuel/operating cost only and not the total cost including capital and maintenance, because the capital and maintenance then have to be paid anyway to make the capacity available at night. It has also been getting installed more in the locations amenable to it -- places with more sunlight, clearer skies and less expensive land. Notice that a lot of the existing capacity is in places like Arizona and not places like Seattle. But once the demand in those locations is satisfied, you have to move to places without those characteristics and you get less power at higher cost. Meanwhile just because you have the existing supply doesn't mean you have the existing supply. You need the price to fall to the level that it becomes economical to generate power even for use at night in Seattle, but that price may be lower than the price that customers in Asia and South America would pay, so even if the supply exists, it ends up going somewhere else first. All this to say that extrapolating from an exponential curve is generally wrong sooner or later, and frequently sooner. > Solar capacity will rise to 100% of today's total capacity, and it still won't displace lots of other energy sources. Why? Because when power is cheaper and has fewer negative externalities, we'll use more of it. If it becomes genuinely cheaper even in northern cities and even with the cost of energy storage, it will displace lots of other energy sources and we'll use more of it. But that's still speculation that may or may not ever actually happen. And maybe it does, but it's still justifiable to be prepared if it doesn't.