10 ms·
If other low-carbon sources, namely wind and solar PV, are to fill the shortfall in nuclear, their deployment would have to accelerate to an unprecedented level
by jessaustin 7y ago
If other low-carbon sources, namely wind and solar PV, are to fill the shortfall in nuclear, their deployment would have to accelerate to an unprecedented level. In the past 20 years, wind and solar PV capacity has increased by about 580 gigawatts in advanced economies. But over the next 20 years, nearly five times that amount would need to be added.
This is misleading enough to make one question every "fact" stated in TFA. 20 years ago was essentially a zero point for the statistic they cite. It was less than 5 gigawatts, anyway. It grew by over 100 times in that 20 years, and it will be "unprecedented" to grow by 5 times in the next 20? (5 < 100) Is anyone at this agency numerate?
Don't believe me, take a look at the charts here:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics
Sure those don't include wind, but when you find those charts they will look the same. Anyway wind isn't growing as fast as solar.
- isolli 7y agoIt reminds me of this: https://twitter.com/AukeHoekstra/status/866313289306963969/photo/1 https://twitter.com/AukeHoekstra/status/866313289306963969/p... tl;dr The International Energy Agency kept predicting, year after year, in the face of all the evidence, that solar production would plateau.
- tim333 7y agoThat's quite impressively wrong from the IEA. I wonder how come.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoOne of the comments there points it out: The government keeps passing subsidies for solar that nominally expire, then renewing them again before they expire. Then the government's models assume the subsidies expire when the law says they will rather than getting renewed time and again.
- pfdietz 7y agoIf you could predict the future, would you work for the IEA?
- tpkj 7y agoWe could be at the point where solar adoption takes off exponentially. On a big picture view: Tony Seba: Clean Disruption - Energy & Transportation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2b3ttqYDwF0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2b3ttqYDwF0 On a more micro level view: Solar power solutions coming to places with no grid: https://medium.com/zolaelectric/infinity-smart-grid-delivering-clean-affordable-reliable-24-hour-power-for-anyone-anywhere-70382e8aef7f https://medium.com/zolaelectric/infinity-smart-grid-deliveri...
- ben_w 7y agoIt has taken off exponentially. That’s what the growth curve you’re looking at is called. :)
- tpkj 7y agoNo, it has not taken off exponentially yet in the way the Tony Seba video demonstrates with a picture of 5th Ave in NYC in the year 1900 where there are lots of horses used for transportation, and only one car, compared with a picture of the same street in 1913, where the street is full of cars, and there is only one horse to be found.
- jessaustin 7y agoScroll down the page I linked to the graph "Exponential Growth of Solar PV". A straight line on a log graph is exponential by definition.
- tpkj 7y agoThere's the formal definition of "exponential", and then there is "exponential" in the sense of completely disruptive and transformative as in the example Tony Seba gives. I am referring to the latter.
- jessaustin 7y agoAt least they're consistent. If linear growth is the only thing they can imagine, then they definitely can't imagine exponential growth.
- grecy 7y agoReported facts are no longer actual hard facts as we once knew them. Reporting is just some companies interpretation of a situation so they will influence people so they can continue to make as much profit as possible. Unfortunately, we have to take absolutely everything with a grain of salt.
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoErr, they say production grew by 580 GW in the past 20 years and that it must grow by another 5x580=2,900 GW in the next 5 years. Nothing misleading and indeed an unprecedented production increase. It's not the ratio that is hard, it's the raw amount.
- tim333 7y agoDepends if you are looking at it as growing linearly or exponentially. You can make an argument solar is growing exponentially, doubling ever so often, at the moment.
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoThe point remains.
- abdullahkhalids 7y ago> their deployment would have to accelerate to an __unprecedented__ level Parent comments point is that the 5x growth is not unprecedentedly fast compared to the past 20 years, its unprecedentedly slow compared to the past 20 years. Contrary to what the quote claims, and in line with projections from the past, the solar business would have to seriously slow down to miss the 5x milestone.
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoAnd what I replied is that this is not the point of the article, and that ratios in themselves are not the relevant metric. The article is clear and accurate. Deploying close to 3000 GW is an unprecedented effort.
- maxerickson 7y agoYou've picked the wrong number of years, the article says But over the next 20 years, nearly five times that amount would need to be added. The current linear growth trajectory is 2,000 GW over 20 years, and that is likely to be a hilarious underestimate.
- dclowd9901 7y agoGoing from 5-580 is much easier than going from 580->2500. Just ask anyone how hard it was to make their first 100,000, million, billion, etc. Using multiples is actually oversimplifying the issue (i.e. "to make a hundred dollars, you just have to make $10 10 times, so making $1000 from $100 should be just as easy")
- jessaustin 7y agoNot that I would necessarily know, but I always heard that the first million was the hardest? You seem to be arguing in support of my point? That is, switch out "first million dollars" for "first 580 gigawatts".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rndgermandude 7y agoNo, that's not how it works. It's hard in the beginning, because of research and development. After that, you got the technology side covered, you got the processes side covered, all you need is to build and install. Making the first mobile phones was hard. Making another million mobile phones today: not that hard. Especially if you make a million more of an established model.
- tomp 7y agoNo, that's not how it works. Every growth process has limits. Solar has much more limits than mobile phones: land, resources (phones are tiny compared to solar panels), labour (not just production, but also placing the panels and maintaining them)... I reckon if we treat solar panels like mobile phones (throw away every 1.5 years) we won't get far...
- Faark 7y agoLimits only matter when we at least start getting close to reaching those. There is enough land, labor and resources for lots of solar panels while most of us in the western world already have a smartphone and seem to replace them less often due to a seemingly slower tech cycle.
- Zigurd 7y agoYou can't overtake oil without spending a comparable amount on developing renewables. While it isn't quite there yet, soon renewables will be a bigger business than oil. That's impressive, and it makes the kind of growth needed to replace nuclear power plausible. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/renewables-investment-overtake-oil-gas-170000937.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/renewables-investment-overtak...
- Retric 7y agoAs renewables are currently vastly cheaper than oil or nuclear, it’s going to take far less investment to reach the same place.
- beat 7y agoThe main reason for the current inflection point is that the cost per unit energy for solar/wind has dropped precipitously (and continues to drop), while the cost/energy for most fossil fuels is growing rapidly (natural gas is an exception, due to new fracking tech). And nuclear is such a massive long-term capital investment in a rapidly developing energy picture that the risk profile is really bad, even if a new plant operates perfectly with no problems for its entire planned lifespan. Nobody wants to be the one who decided to build a nuclear plant for X dollars/gigawatt (most of that cost up-front), only to have solar going for .5X before the new plant is even operational. And it's not just the cost of solar/wind that's dropping... it's the cost of short-term energy storage, by way of batteries/thermal/hydro/etc. Nuclear plants are base-load power, good for long-term stable output rather than quick spikes up and down. But short-term storage allows solar/wind to act as baseline as well, capturing more when the sun is shining and the wind is blowing, and dumping it from storage when needed. Committing to expensive nuclear power plants now, with this much disruption going on, is a good way for a utility to go bankrupt twenty, thirty years from now.
- abalone 7y agoYes and it's interesting to quote the rest of that paragraph, which ends up arguing that clean energy transitions "would end up hurting consumers through higher electricity bills."[1] The use of the term "hurting" here is a tell. Yeah, you know, maybe fixing the planet will require a mobilization on the scale of going to war and result in higher prices. That's not hurting people; that's helping our children live on a planet free of nuclear waste and climate disaster. [1] "Such a drastic increase in renewable power generation would create serious challenges in integrating the new sources into the broader energy system. Clean energy transitions in advanced economies would also require $1.6 trillion in additional investment over the same period, which would end up hurting consumers through higher electricity bills."
- jessaustin 7y agoHaha, this may be the first time in history that nuclear enthusiasts have pretended to give a damn about ratepayers. I'd bet that most of their "$1.6 trillion" figure comes from decommissioning dangerous nuclear plants. We've already spent that money, assholes...
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> 20 years ago was essentially a zero point for the statistic they cite. It was less than 5 gigawatts, anyway. It grew by over 100 times in that 20 years, and it will be "unprecedented" to grow by 5 times in the next 20? Do you expect the growth rate of Google over the next 20 years will be the same as it was between 1999 and today? As things mature you don't get the same level of exponential growth. Meanwhile the subsidies for solar are being reduced etc. And your chart is installed capacity, not panel production capacity. The growth in panel production capacity is lower than that visual implies. But let's suppose we could replace nuclear with solar. That doesn't really work because solar can't produce at night and adding the requirement of batteries would make the demand for daytime-only solar generation fall off significantly, but suppose we could do it. That's still not what we need -- we need the expanding solar capacity to replace coal. Every GW of nuclear it would have to replace is one more GW of coal that stays online.
- andrekandre 7y ago> That doesn't really work because solar can't produce at night photovoltaic no, molten salt yes https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crescent_Dunes_Solar_Energy_Project https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crescent_Dunes_Solar_Energy_... btw, driving by them at daytime is pretty weird... the collectors look literally like close-up stars floating above the surface
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoSure, and so does hydro and geothermal and biomass. But people are interested in photovoltaics because they're cost-competitive (during the day at least).
- aeternus 7y agoAre those actually more environment-friendly than nuclear? Seems like those would take up lots of land area and easily fry and possibly blind animals, especially birds that get too close. They do look cool though.
- petre 7y ago
- singularity2001 7y agoThe growth rate for solar is x10/8 years, so in 20 years we are at >90% solar.
- jessaustin 7y agoI'd believe 90% of current capacity, but it won't get to that portion of total capacity. Solar isn't perfect for every situation. Even so, when energy is cheaper with fewer negative externalities, we'll use more of it.
- singularity2001 7y agocapacity growth is already factored in: Global energy consumption is doubling only every 20 years.