5 ms·
Greenpeace has successfully spent several decades painting nuclear power as Evil so its going to be difficult to convince voters to support it from now on.
by ekianjo 7y ago
Greenpeace has successfully spent several decades painting nuclear power as Evil so its going to be difficult to convince voters to support it from now on.
- pjc50 7y agoHoisting my previous comment on Greenpeace from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17774347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17774347 The backlash against nuclear comes from four points and a meta-point: 1) Weapons proliferation. The standard fission cycle is just too convenient for this (after all, that's why it was developed) and so an international infrastructure needs to be developed around restricting this. See Iran for example. This also prompted a lot of opposition from people who didn't want to live under the threat of their cities being nuked. This also turned into lethal fights with the environmental movement (the French government sank Greenpeace's ship Rainbow Warrior with a terrorist bombing that killed a photographer, over the question of nuclear weapons testing). A difficult bit of bad blood to bury. 2) Huge scale and persistence of accidents. Chernobyl affected agriculture in the whole of Western Europe, and took decades for an adequate final containment to be built. Bhopal was bad - and possibly worse in effects! - but at least the area isn't a permanent wasteland. Pebble bed reactors were deemed the promising future, until one of them jammed. It's now unfixable and practically impossible to decomission: (wikipedia) "There exists currently no dismantling method for the AVR vessel, but it is planned to develop some procedure during the next 60 years and to start with vessel dismantling at the end of the century." 3) Waste disposal. A forever problem. I'm old enough to remember Greenpeace fighting it being dumped at sea, but the problem of where we put it remains. 4) Cost overruns. A systematic problem in the industry. Doesn't affect renewables to anything like the same extent. 5) The meta-point: systematic lying about the effects of all of the above. That this happens to overlap with the era of discovering that all sorts of previous advances (CFCs, tetraethyl lead, DDT, asbestos) had nasty side-effects which were also lied about or minimised is not a coincidence. Nuclear advocates take the arrogant position that they don't need to win trust.
- benj111 7y agoAll reasonable points, but would you not agree that in the here and now, our first priority should be replacing that coal power station with renewables, and then the gas, then the nuclear?
- Ygg2 7y agoThat's also a bit impossible. There aren't any easy solutions going forward. You want to replace most power station with non-base load renewables (wind + solar). Well, at peak power are going to add more batteries, to make sure your energy doesn't go to waste. Want to add more batteries, oh you'll need more renewable sources keep it net positive during the winter months and probably keep those battery from draining completely. This is ofc, before the quetion arises, what happens if you have weeks/months of no sun at all :) Geothermal? Not everyone has access plus possible increases in tectonic activity. Hydro? Not everyone has access plus possible destruction of ecosystems. Burning waste to produce power? Probably not enough burnable waste. Don't get me wrong. Solar scales great if you have a backup to fallback to. California going from 1.9-2.5% of solar would cost as much as a small nuclear plant (around $18 billion dollars).
- benj111 7y agoImpossible? Its prioritising. Theres a significant number of Greens that are against nuclear. And rather than infight about that, I'd rather work on what we all do agree on first. Once we've decarbonised the grid then we can have the discussion about nuclear. What I don't want is any other countries doing a Germany and pissing away time and money turning off nuclear reactors whilst still burning coal.
- pjc50 7y agoThat seems reasonable - no point in closing functioning, safe, carbon free plant that's already been paid for. The UK has already almost entirely replaced coal.
- benj111 7y ago
- ElKrist 7y agoThanks for pointing that out. Greenpeace is the perfect example of how "fighting for the environment" is meaningless. Are we talking about biodiversity, air pollution, water pollution, side effects of mining... or climate change? Unfortunately, it's hard to find something that works for all of these problems. Except reducing consumption overall.