2 ms·
There are many ways to achieve success and fulfillment that do not involve attending an elite college. Instead of encouraging people to pursue options well-matc
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
There are many ways to achieve success and fulfillment that do not involve attending an elite college. Instead of encouraging people to pursue options well-matched to their abilities, however, we tell young people that their self-worth hinges entirely on the brand name on their college diploma.
Oh, please. They make it sound like going to a top school is simply about ego enhancement. It's more like about enhancing your net worth in the long run.
Grade inflation is probably about two forces colliding:
1. Schools being used primarily for credentialing rather than for educating per se.
2. Increased awareness of "diversity" issues, for lack of a better term.
What you see is that members of some in group -- in this case upper class cis het white males -- generally get scored better than members of various out groups, such as women, people of color and LGBTQ. There are various factor as to why that is, but part of the problem is straight up prejudice. There is plenty of evidence that if an in group member does x, it gets credit and when an out group member does the exact same thing, it doesn't get the same credit.
So there is a legitimate argument to be made that if your grades at a college most strongly correlate to a particular demographic rather than performance - especially if that demographic is the known and long standing in group that controls everything -- then those grades aren't really measuring performance per se to begin with. Thus they are merely a credentialing mechanism being used to exclude out group members and perpetuate historical injustices.
The problem is that passing out As like candy doesn't actually fix prejudice and social exclusion. It merely serves to erode the value of the signal that grades are supposed to provide.
I don't know what the solution is. But I suspect that's a large part of the mechanism driving such trends.