5 ms·
The prime numbers of course would have been just fine and irreducible as ever if Hegel had never existed. He did however manage to influence a lot of other iffy
by tim333 7y ago
The prime numbers of course would have been just fine and irreducible as ever if Hegel had never existed. He did however manage to influence a lot of other iffy stuff:
> Maurice Merleau-Ponty wrote that "all the great philosophical ideas of the past century—the philosophies of Marx and Nietzsche, phenomenology, German existentialism, and psychoanalysis—had their beginnings in Hegel."(wikipedia)
- claudiawerner 7y agoThe prime numbers would also be irreducible if there weren't mathematicians, though. To use Feynman's analogy, birds would still be doing what birds do even if it weren't for ornithologists. Although the author is a Marxist economist (and I have some sympathies with him), it's probably better to consider Hegel on his own grounds - Hegelianism does not lead to Marxism and existentialism just as rationalism does not lead to the ontological argument. On the contrary, far from being iffy, I'd say that Marx and Nietzche (even if you would only concede due to their fundamental place in the culture of suspicion - doubting the notions they doubted) and existentialism from that list, at least, are worthy of some praise. Psychoanalysis is a different beast, but there has been some interesting recent (post-Popper, which I must mention since people seem to end psychoanalysis with Popper which seems premature) work on it, even from outsiders and psychologists.
- intuitionist 7y ago> The prime numbers would also be irreducible if there weren't mathematicians, though. This is a lot more philosophically fraught. If you believe that mathematical entities exist in some acausal, nonphysical realm separate from the activity of beings doing math, you need to explain how those beings can access them. If you take Brouwer’s position that mathematics is the free languageless creation of the mind, then it’s no longer true that prime numbers would be irreducible if not for mathematicians.
- claudiawerner 7y agoThat's true, and I accept that - though my claim was more intended to attack the notion that a certain analysis is useless just because the thing being analyzed would exist otherwise - whether that existence is due to initial theorists (i.e primes are a creation of the mind) or whether it's due to their non-physical existence as Platonic forms was a little beside the point of what I was trying to say. I meant it more in the way that we could say science would still exist even if Popper hadn't theorized falsificationism.
- Nasrudith 7y agoI don't see how that follows personally - mathematics are about configuration of information which may or may not be descriptions that exist within reality. Impetus based momentum could be described mathematically but that doesn't mean it exists. Which highlights Hegel's central flaw in derivation - possibilities are infinite without any grounding assumptions. At best you would get a smaller but still infinite subset compared to literally everything (all valis equations vs all equations even 2 = 1). There is no need to "access" what may simply be rederived. It isn't a physical place. The only constraints are on what configurations are possible within the system attempting to describe it. You can't describe 0 to 1024 with only a single bit. In a "world of silence" with no "life" capable of describing primes it would still hold that the smallest non-1 divisions of 6 particles would be 2 and 3 and for 7 it would be 7 - even though there is nobody around to understand this.
- claudiawerner 7y agoIt's worth noting that the idea that mathematical forms are mind-independent and can be "accessed" is taken seriously by non-crackpot philosophers. It's not a settled matter. See the SEP[0] entry for some of the debates surrounding it. A nice passage is: >This counterfactual independence (as we may call it) is accepted by most analytic philosophers. To see why, consider the role that mathematics plays in our reasoning. We often reason about scenarios that aren’t actual. Were we to build a bridge across this canyon, say, how strong would it have to be to withstand the powerful gusts of wind? Sadly, the previous bridge collapsed. Would it have done so had the steel girders been twice as thick? This form of reasoning about counterfactual scenarios is indispensable both to our everyday deliberations and to science. The permissibility of such reasoning has an important consequence. Since the truths of pure mathematics can freely be appealed to throughout our counterfactual reasoning, it follows that these truths are counterfactually independent of us humans, and all other intelligent life for that matter. That is, had been there been no intelligent life, these truths would still have remained the same. [0] https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/platonism-mathematics/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/platonism-mathematics/
- tim333 7y agoYou can suppose we can figure they exist using logic and reasoning rather needing access to some mystical realm.
- beat 7y agoI don't think of any of those things as "iffy", myself. But if you wanna take a shot at dismissing anything that Nietzsche or Heidegger wrote, without resorting to cultural bias points, be my guest. There's a PhD in it for you.
- theoh 7y agoThey might be seen as iffy because of the damage that has been done in the name of each of their theories. Marx obviously has a lot to answer for if you consider him responsible for everything that went wrong in the USSR; Freud's influence is probably as much bad as good, if you consider it as having brought a compelling but pseudoscientific method to bear on psychology. And so on. It does sound anti-intellectual to dismiss all those thinkers as iffy, but I'd much rather retain the option of treating their views with skepticism than enrol in a PhD programme where it's implicit that all one can do is write footnotes on the work of these great men. (You seem to imply that — unless, that is, the student is a rare and impertinent genius who has the temerity to take them on.)
- Avshalom 7y agoto steal a line from Stroustrup: "there are to kinds of philosophies: the ones people kill each other over and the ones nobody uses"
- tim333 7y agoThough some like humanism tend to lead to less killing than might have gone on otherwise.
- xamuel 7y agoLet it run its full course, and humanism will lead to an unimaginably horrific dystopia. Think "Brave New World", by Aldous Huxley. The surest way to make a man stumble and fall is to puff him up with flattery and tell him how wise and sure-footed he is.