4 ms·
My problem with sites like manufactum is that I have the feeling that I get exactly the same stuff as I would get from somewhere else but with an insane price m
by adrianN 7y ago
My problem with sites like manufactum is that I have the feeling that I get exactly the same stuff as I would get from somewhere else but with an insane price markup. I can either buy a random organic cotton shirt for thirty Euros, or I can buy an organic cotton shirt from manufactum and pay four times as much. What's the extra value I get?
- _petronius 7y agoAt the very least, a price point that doesn’t externalize the real environmental cost of the item, perhaps?
- kkarakk 7y agoUnless you're a "brain-washed hippy environmental activist", the markup definitely feels like a ripoff - which is the fundamental problem with any ethical shopping website. I'd gladly pay Amazon price + 5 dollars,any more and my ethics bow down to my trained budgeting
- _petronius 7y agoWhich probably accounts for a lot of people's behaviours, but the real cost of most products is going to be more like 100-500% markup, not a flat $5, especially once you get into cheap flights or items that have been shipped large distances. I'm not someone who believes that changes in individual consumer behaviour is going to keep up under 5 degrees of global warming, but if we don't start getting used to some of this, then there will never be the political will to enact the policies that will head off the worst of climate change.
- gambiting 7y agoI'd be ok with all stores everywhere being hit with a plastic tariff that meant that a plastic bucket cost 25 euro. I'm not ok with spending 25 euro on a bucket[0] "just because" - it just feels like I'm stuffing someone's pocket at that point. [0]https://www.manufactum.com/swiss-plastic-bin-p1448058/?a=77250 https://www.manufactum.com/swiss-plastic-bin-p1448058/?a=772...
- jakobegger 7y agoYou are paying for someone in Switzerland to make a high quality bucket. Yes, that person earns a lot more than the average chinese factory worker. But in exchange you get a better bucket. I've had a lot of cheap plastic buckets break, so I kinda understand why someone would want to get a better plastic bucket.
- dual_basis 7y agoI agree with incorporating negative externalities into the cost of a product, but if the money isn't actually going toward paying for those externalities then it's just profit for the owner.
- adrianN 7y agoIt's not like the extra Euros are used for sucking carbon out of the atmosphere or cleaning up the oceans. They'll most likely end up in Manufactum's pocket.
- jakobegger 7y agoThe stuff from Manufactum is not comparable to cheap stuff from somewhere else. It's a lot better quality. It's not just "organic cotton"; there's a lot more that differentiates products from Manufactum than just the type of cotton it is made from. You can see from the extremely elaborate description that they write about every manufacturer (it's a German store, so the English texts aren't as detailed) that they don't just resell random stuff from far away factories. They put a lot of thought into the products they offer. Usually Manufactum isn't the cheapest option, but their markup is not as bad as you think. If you can find the item at other stores, it'll cost about the same (+/- 10%). For example, this Herder knife costs 94€ plus shipping at Manufactum [1] and 109€ with free shipping at Amazon [2]. [1]: https://www.manufactum.at/herder-kuechenmesser-kesselscher-walkschliff-p1461766/?a=41246 https://www.manufactum.at/herder-kuechenmesser-kesselscher-w... [2]: https://www.amazon.de/Windmühle-Messer-Windmühlenmesser-Universalmesser-Hechtsäbels/dp/B002LJ102U/ref=pd_sbs_201_1/262-4962699-1636758?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=B002LJ102U&pd_rd_r=a3d307aa-8125-11e9-8290-1f7ef5cdf6ea&pd_rd_w=hlAcQ&pd_rd_wg=3N2UU&pf_rd_p=74d946ea-18de-4443-bed6-d8837f922070&pf_rd_r=EGTY4ZS2ZXHV5SRZY1AR&psc=1&refRID=EGTY4ZS2ZXHV5SRZY1AR https://www.amazon.de/Windmühle-Messer-Windmühlenmesser-Univ...
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI share GP's worry. Long descriptions are only proof they spend more on content. Given the sleaziness of on-line retailers in general, how can I tell this is a genuine signal and not faked one?
- jakobegger 7y agoYou'll have to take my word! Manufactum is not a random online retailer. They have been around for some time, and have a certain reputation around here. They have been selling things from a paper catalog before the internet got popular. They actually still have paper catalogs, and reading them is a wonderful pastime. (I don't really use the website much, unless I am looking for something specific) But even if you don't trust me, at least they have very detailed descriptions and high resolution photographs of the products on their site. And if you order something, and you end up not liking it, you can always return it (eg. for a leather bag it's hard to judge from a photograph if you like it or not).