4 ms·
It's easy to laugh the old incidents. But it's pointless without considering the situation at that time. Otherwise, it's like laughing at old movies, saying: "W
by ezoe 7y ago
It's easy to laugh the old incidents. But it's pointless without considering the situation at that time. Otherwise, it's like laughing at old movies, saying: "Why don't they use cellphone to communicate each other?". The cellphone haven't invented at that time.
Japanese navy suffered beriberi for eating milled white rice and nothing else. Because milled rice only diet lacks essential vitamins. But the first vitamin hasn't been found until 1913(Vitamin A). Nobody in the world had a correct knowledge about healthy diet. In this case, eating un-milled brown rice.
At that time, majority of them believed that beriberi was caused by some kind of bacteria. So Japanese navy did everything they could do to prevent infection. It was not like they were trying. They didn't know the correct solution.
So your next question would be, why didn't they test it scientifically? Well, in 1880, Statistics hadn't been developed like today. So not many people, even the scientists didn't have a proper statistic knowledge like modern scientists today must has or else they are doomed to be called unscientific idiot.
You must also consider that at that time, the brown rice was for poor. It's taste aren't that good compared to white rice. Rich people was enjoy eating white rice everyday. Now imagine you were drafted for military, serving for the country, and you can't get a delicious and enough meal. That' a shame. So Japanese navy serve the best meal the traditional Japanese soldiers want, a lot of white rice.
- DuskStar 7y ago...because no other navy had encountered issues from feeding their crew a monotonous diet before. Maybe not this specific set of issues, but issues nonetheless.
- ezoe 7y agoUntil very recently, traditional Japanese meal was consists of a bowl of rice, miso soup with some vegetables, and some vegetables. Because of religious and cultural reason(it was not that strong ban but most people follow it), Japanese at that time rarely eat meat.
- DuskStar 7y agoAnd what relevance does that have? That's not the diet the sailors in question had or the replacement diet that was proposed.
- masklinn 7y agoThe issue wasn't restricted to the navy, and was especially present in the urban upper class (including the imperial clan), so much so that it was nicknamed "edo disease" as polished white rice was much more easily obtained in Edo (given enough means) than in more provincials cities. Interestingly, early industrialisation made things worse: mechanical mills made the desirable polished white rice way more accessible to all.
- kstenerud 7y agoYou haven't read the article. It already speaks to all of your points, and highlights the navy's (and later the army's) resistance to change, even in the face of irrefutable evidence. Only the direct word of the emperor was enough to bring them to heel.