3 ms·
The plaintiff needs a unanimous decision by the jury to win, and has a limited amount of time to present arguments and to counter defense arguments. The Court a
by tzs 7y ago
The plaintiff needs a unanimous decision by the jury to win, and has a limited amount of time to present arguments and to counter defense arguments. The Court actually keeps track of time used, and will cut them when they hit the limit.
The more uniform your audience is, the better chance you have to craft an argument that will work with all of them.
Suppose the trial involves some specialized field, and you have a jury with a wide range of knowledge about that field. Both plaintiff and defendant are going to include in their cases an explanation of the relevant field, pitched for the backgrounds of the jurors with the least prior knowledge.
If the jury also has people who are experts in that field, there are at least three potential problems.
1. They are going to be bored during the part where you are explaining the field to the rest of the jury, and might let their minds wander, and might miss something important.
2. Your primer on their field necessarily simplifies things, and if you simplify in a different way than they would, it could prejudice them against your case.
3. The other jurors may turn to them for guidance on the evidence relating to that field. That's problematical for two reasons.
3a. If the evidence relating to the field is in an area where experts in that field disagree, the other jurors will get the position of the expert juror, and will probably give that more weight than the testimony of exports at trial who take a different position.
In effect, the expert juror ends up also as a de facto expert witness in the trial--but an expert witness not subject to examination or cross examination.
3b. There is a danger that if the jury turns to the expert juror for help on the technical evidence, they will also tend to give more weight to that juror's opinion on the rest of evidence.
- jancsika 7y agoThat unfortunately applies to other areas as well, like critical thinkers. It makes me curious-- suppose the judge asks a potential juror if there is any reason they cannot remain impartial. What happens if that potential juror responds yes, pointing out that the plantiff's lawyer had clearly been systematically dismissing the independent thinkers from the jury for the past four hours?
- saghm 7y agoMostly likely, that person won't be picked for jury then. That being said, when I served on a jury for a lawsuit earlier this year, we were informed about whether we were selected outside of the room where the remaining potential jurors were still sitting, meaning the people still in the room had no idea which of us were picked, since from their perspective, we would leave either way. Interestingly, there also wasn't a judge present for this selection, only the lawyers; apparently in my jurisdiction (New York City), judges are only present for the selection of jurors for criminal trials, not civil.