2 ms·
People improperly conflate public active funds, which are not incentivized to outperform, with all portfolios. Funds that consistently outperform for a very lon
by jandrewrogers 7y ago
People improperly conflate public active funds, which are not incentivized to outperform, with all portfolios. Funds that consistently outperform for a very long time almost universally end up closed or are prop trading shops, the latter which would have no reason to exist if they didn't outperform. All of these have practical scaling limits but it isn't inordinately difficult. Only comparing indexes to public active funds is a bit of a straw man because it actively selects for under-performers.
I'm a long-term risk modeler, originally for fun and later for profit. I build portfolios of US large caps based on categories of risk that are not priced into the market because they are difficult to model in a conventional way. This is an entirely uncontroversial way to outperform indexes but you wouldn't build a public investment vehicle around it. My oldest continuous portfolio goes back to the turn of the century, at around 20-21% ARR (more recent portfolios are a bit better). Per year, it requires maybe several hours of my time. I have a few friends and acquaintances that seem to do a bit better (but also spend more time on it) that also trade on un-/mis-priced risk, often as a justification to polish their data science skills, across a variety of asset classes.
I am not saying it is trivial to consistently outperform the indexes, just that the difficulty is significantly overstated. The hurdle most people trip over is that there are no shortcuts to figuring out how to build your own models from first principles and how to trade them.
- pedrocr 7y ago>I am not saying it is trivial to consistently outperform the indexes, just that the difficulty is significantly overstated. The difficulty isn't overstated because in aggregate it's mathematically impossible. The total market return is zero-sum so someone else has to take the other side of your bets and lose return. That someone else is not me, I'm getting the market average consistently to within a decimal point from my index fund. Here's Sharpe's simple take on it: https://web.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/active/active.htm https://web.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/active/active.htm
- 55555 7y ago> This need not be taken as a counsel of despair. It is perfectly possible for some active managers to beat their passive brethren, even after costs. Such managers must, of course, manage a minority share of the actively managed dollars within the market in question. It is also possible for an investor (such as a pension fund) to choose a set of active managers that, collectively, provides a total return better than that of a passive alternative, even after costs. Not all the managers in the set have to beat their passive counterparts, only those managing a majority of the investor's actively managed funds. For anyone who misreads the subtleties of your post and thinks they cant make consistent alpha through active management. They can, but (without knowing anything about them) probably won't.
- pedrocr 7y agoOh, it's definitely possible to outperform. And for every bit of that performance someone else is taking the losing side of that bet. What most people must realize is that as retail investors with no special insight into the market the chance that someone is giving them a chance to be on the winning side of the bets is not great. If you can't identify who the sucker is, it's probably you, so taking the average at low fees is your best bet.
- 55555 7y agoWhere do you discuss this with like-minded people? Where do you read/write about this?