4 ms·
I don’t think the issue is a small group of people holding a vision. For me, the issue is that a company changes the vision based on some unknown goals that the
by prepend 7y ago
I don’t think the issue is a small group of people holding a vision. For me, the issue is that a company changes the vision based on some unknown goals that the company has that are not known to the community.
I think it’s disingenuous to paint this as a tyranny of the masses type situation as no one is calling for democracy. And even if they did, Apache and Python are showing successes in that area.
If google wanted an OSS language, they would have non-google committers. It’s perfectly cool to have company run languages. I think people just need to be aware and not confused that Go is anything other than Google’s language that we all get to use for free.
For me, with almost all things google, the risk is when Google grows bored with this and makes all the employees work on other stuff.
- xyzzy_plugh 7y ago> And even if they did, Apache and Python are showing successes in that area. I find both of these communities to be huge turn offs. I think Apache projects and Python demonstrate varied quality; design by committee. Conversely I find Go releases to be pretty high quality. When they are marginally suspect, I tend to find the strongest critics are members of the Go core team (e.g. future of http, sql packages). > If google wanted an OSS language, they would have non-google committers. I don't buy this line of reasoning. Go has been extremely welcoming to contributors. You don't need to be a committee to contribute. Are the thousands of projects open sourced by corporations under their corporate GitHub account not _true_ OSS to you? > For me, with almost all things google, the risk is when Google grows bored with this and makes all the employees work on other stuff. I understand this, but it's FUD. We've heard nothing but positive feedback from Googlers (no "they won't let us do X"), and if this _did_ happen, I would expect the existing committers to rebel sufficiently (i.e. quit) that this problem solves itself. Until then, I see no cause to warrant a change in management.
- ridiculous_fish 7y ago> If google wanted an OSS language, they would have non-google committers Ian claims "59 Googlers on the committers list and 51 non-Googlers." I was surprised by that too.