3 ms·
There is an equilibrium point between indexed and non-indexed portfolios in terms of optimizing expected returns. Capital will move to whatever portfolio type i
by jandrewrogers 7y ago
There is an equilibrium point between indexed and non-indexed portfolios in terms of optimizing expected returns. Capital will move to whatever portfolio type is giving the best returns if too much of the market is composed of one or the other. More money moving into indexing makes it easier to outperform the index because there are fewer investors competing to profit from mis-priced equities, making those positions cheaper to acquire. Anecdotally, I find it easier to outperform the indexes today than it was fifteen years ago.
Even if the entire market is indexing, there are still fundamental mechanisms that will keep it responsive. Markets are indexed in many ways depending on what aspect of the market the indexes are trying to capture, and these different indexes weight and value the underlying stocks differently, with some indexes outperforming others which will drive allocation of capital to different indexes. And at the extremes, over-valuation is addressed by bankruptcy and under-valuation is addressed by taking a company private, removing companies from the market entirely.