2 ms·
Seeing those who try to profit by breaking/abusing our legal structure smacked down is always cathartic - this particular instance has a hilarious portion of th
by munk-a 7y ago
Seeing those who try to profit by breaking/abusing our legal structure smacked down is always cathartic - this particular instance has a hilarious portion of the judgement in refusing the ability for the filer to censor what they filed over. Intellectual property is valuable and industrial espionage from actors who are not held to account by US law is a real issue - but in theory that's what patents are there for. Your IP no longer needs to be kept under lock and key since it's registered with the government and you are given legal recourse to seek damages if someone uses that information - this is the mechanism I appreciate the most from our patent system and I hope we preserve it when we revise the system to be less stupid about other things.
The fact that this troll was arguing that they couldn't reveal the way in which their IP was infringed publicly as it would hurt their business is hilarious as it's absolutely true and depressing at the same time - their business is hoping that other companies accidentally trip into patent violations, they don't want those violators to negotiate usage fees upfront nor do they want the violators to carefully avoid violating the patent.
- rayiner 7y agoThe article isn't about infringement, but standing. Uniloc is arguing that it cannot disclose the business arrangements by which it purchased the right to assert the patents at issue.
- deogeo 7y agoSuch shady tactics aren't limited to small companies - Microsoft kept its Android patents secret for as long as possible: https://www.zdnet.com/article/310-microsoft-patents-used-in-android-licensing-agreements-revealed-by-chinese-gov/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/310-microsoft-patents-used-in-...
- Wistar 7y agoMicrosoft did not try to keep their Android patents secret but did try to keep secret the list of which of their Android patents were used in licensing deals. This is a key difference as, unlike patents, licensing deals and the list of patents included in those deals are not public information and keeping them confidential does not seem to me to be "shady." The individual patents, provided you knew which were involved, could and can be easily looked up and read.
- deogeo 7y ago> This is a key difference It is a distinction without a difference - without knowing which patents are 'Android patents' (i.e. the ones in the licensing deals), avoiding them is impossible.
- Wistar 7y agoA two-term USPTO search for "Microsoft" and "Android" plus any terms specific to the technolog(ies) you are interested in reveals their patents.
- tzs 7y agoCould you find them by looking at the patent markings on Android devices (or in the accompanying documents) made by companies that licensed the patents? The patent licensing deal that granted them the right to use those patents should have included a requirement that they mark.
- deogeo 7y agoFrom the wording of that story I assume no, or it wouldn't have required the Chinese government to reveal them.
- zebraflask 7y agoNothing quite like a bench slap. One of my favorite judges.