3 ms·
Isn't C++ committee-driven, which could be considered a type of democratic process? Or would that not be considered an open-source project? On that note, I als
by tsimionescu 7y ago
Isn't C++ committee-driven, which could be considered a type of democratic process? Or would that not be considered an open-source project?
On that note, I also seem to remember that LLVM/Clang are pretty democratic, but I haven't dug deeply and may be completely wrong.
- gradys 7y agoThe analogy Go : C++ :: Go's governance : C++'s governance works pretty well. Maybe C++ is a good example of this, and maybe that is a good way to build a language like C++, but it might be a bad way to make a language like Go.
- repolfx 7y agoLarge parts of Java are handled via the Java Community Process.
- pizza234 7y agoWell, interestingly, "design by comittee" is a pejorative, so it raises the question whether C++ is, in a (specific, not universal) sense, a success or not.
- einpoklum 7y agoC++'s design by committee is well-suited to achieve one of the key goals in the (ongoing) design on the language, which is maintaining extreme backwards compatibility and extensive mulling of potential changes by numerous independent interested parties so that changes that do make it in are nearly-consensual. You could argue whether those are the goals a language should pursue, but it's pretty obvious a central designer with free reign would not have achieved those goals.