4 ms·
> NO ONE knows the answers to these questions, NO ONE knew the answers to those same questions about active investment either, though. Markets are markets, an
by ajross 7y ago
> NO ONE knows the answers to these questions,
NO ONE knew the answers to those same questions about active investment either, though. Markets are markets, and behave in crazy unstable pro-cyclic ways because of psychology, not abstract theory.
Here's an obvious hypothesis: Nothing's going to change at all. The fraction of holdings in these index funds is high, but matches the fraction that was always just thrown into the "balanced random junk" segments of portfolios. Players who want to make focused bets on particular securities or industries will continue to do so, in exactly the same proportion they did before.
I mean, NO ONE knows if that is true or not, but I'd put money down on it.
- cs702 7y agoIt's possible. I did not make any claims to the contrary. That said, in the event of market stress, it seems that more individual portfolios will be more highly correlated with each other than in the past. Isn't that a significant change? In light of it, are you willing to bet that aggregate investor behavior in a future period of stress will be similar to what we have seen in the past?
- aaronblohowiak 7y agoMaybe it will contribute to the increased correlation between stocks and other investments
- ac29 7y ago> The fraction of holdings in these index funds is high, but matches the fraction that was always just thrown into the "balanced random junk" segments of portfolios. Players who want to make focused bets on particular securities or industries will continue to do so, in exactly the same proportion they did before. 30 years ago investing in Index style mutual funds was pretty uncommon. 50 years ago Index funds didn't even exist, and you'd have to have significant wealth to own hundreds or thousands of individual stocks (especially anywhere close to market weighted). We are seeing a fundamental shift in how people invest, though whether or not that leads to a fundamentally different outcome is unknown.