3 ms·
> Two reasonable people with different experiences (and hence different priors) can interpret the same evidence in wholly different ways. I don't understand ho
by taneq 7y ago
> Two reasonable people with different experiences (and hence different priors) can interpret the same evidence in wholly different ways.
I don't understand how this could possibly be otherwise? Thinking about it more, the problem lies in the juxtaposition of "two reasonable people with different experiences" and "the same evidence", since the evidence you're evaluating is always really the sum total (or distillate, at least) of all evidence you've ever seen. You can't just give someone a new fact in a vacuum and ask them to evaluate it without letting the entire rest of their experience affect that evaluation.