4 ms·
For some deontologists, one key difference is that (they claim) you have a natural right to how your physical property is used, but you do not have a natural ri
by jessriedel 16y ago
For some deontologists, one key difference is that (they claim) you have a natural right to how your physical property is used, but you do not have a natural right to how your intellectual production is used. Rather, intellectual property is a device created by the state to foster intellectual production. One consequence is that right to your shoes never expires, but patents only last 17 years.
So trains are fundamentally different, because to ride one is to use someone's property against their will, and so you violate a natural right. When you pirate music, you are only breaking laws. Although breaking the law might be considered immoral, it is for a fundamentally different reason. There are definitely more cases where people think it's acceptable to break the law, especially if there net utility to society goes up. Examples of this would be
(1) parking in one of many handicap parking spaces at night when there is negligible chance that they will all be filled
(2) pirating music that you would not buy if you had to pay for it (you sincerely claim!).