2 ms·
> There has to be more to it than that. Why? What is it? > Works of art have historically required some effort. Effort is not a reliable or particularly good
by dahart 7y ago
> There has to be more to it than that.
Why? What is it?
> Works of art have historically required some effort.
Effort is not a reliable or particularly good metric at all. Conceptual art as a genre is not based on effort, sometimes intentionally eschews effort, and there are many famous conceptual artists in the last century that have been accused of low effort yet still changed the world.
> There has to be some standard, and these pieces should be amenable to criticism. Otherwise, how would one distinguish someone’s garbage dumb [sic] from a piece of art? You can’t.
Correct. You can’t, and you never could. There is no such standard, and there does not have to be a standard. This is art, not logic. The questions “what is art?” and “is this piece art or garbage?” has always existed and always will.
> As for the goldfish in a blender...that is also low effort and provides no real insight on human nature.
Goldfish in a blender as a piece of art tautologically says something about human nature. To do something like that is human. To think it’s silly is human. To write it off as low effort is human. To be concerned for the fish while we’re blind to the animal and environmental destruction our economy brings is human. The only way to deny that it’s making any statement on human nature is to not put any effort into it and not think about it.