4 ms·
I think that's just a restatement of the point. In order to understand, and therefore create a model, you need to have a complete and thorough understanding of
by simonh 7y ago
I think that's just a restatement of the point. In order to understand, and therefore create a model, you need to have a complete and thorough understanding of the original, so in terms of comprehension of the problem domain the model doesn't help much.
- PeterisP 7y agoHow about one of the classic examples of 'wrong but useful' models that is Newtonian physics / 'billiard ball' mechanics? Newton didn't have to have a complete and thorough understanding of how physics actually work, the model is not an intentional simplification but subtly wrong because noone know better at the time; however, the Newtonian model still is really helpful in comprehension of the problem domain so we still teach it to students and use it in practice.
- simonh 7y agoThe discussion is about systems that are too complex for us to understand in their original form. For such highly complex systems, accurate models also sometimes have to be so complex we can't understand them either. For simple systems, obviously this is not as much of a problem, or not a problem at all.
- mannykannot 7y agoMy point is that the quoted passage claims, as a fact, something that is merely a hypothesis, and not a well-supported one at that. For example, we have useful models of the weather and climate, despite the intractability of fluid dynamics.