3 ms·
Only glanced at this but is this like Urbit without the weird homesteading politics? It seems like a revival of the semantic web with RDF and all. I just don't
by Barrin92 7y ago
Only glanced at this but is this like Urbit without the weird homesteading politics? It seems like a revival of the semantic web with RDF and all.
I just don't think this is ever going to work, because this form of decentralisation just doesn't scale. The complexity that comes with separating data and computation and the standards and protocols that need to be invented to get everyone to talk to each other just don't provide enough utility.
We've put data into companies and silos becaues there's actually value to this division of labour. The hierarchies that Solid and others try to combat emerge naturally.
- ghusbands 7y agoA very broad dismissal of a useful concept, with no real substance. Just because it is easier and cheaper to keep data in company silos doesn't mean that will always be kept there. People are trying to make a difference.
- Barrin92 7y agoI don't think that the dismissal has no substance. If it's cheaper and easier to hand the storage and management of data over to a third party, that's a pretty big reason to do it. If there's two fundamental things people care about, it's price and convenience. And I'm sorry, but these semantic web ideas are 30 years old. Adoption is practically non-existent. Do you really think the burden of proof where the value is really is on me?