6 ms·
Interesting view. You write: “The reality is that we don't know enough yet to create any sort of working model of the whole human brain and its thinking proces
by hhs 7y ago
Interesting view. You write: “The reality is that we don't know enough yet to create any sort of working model of the whole human brain and its thinking processes.”
To me, this sentence seems to mean that it may be possible some time down the road to “know enough” and create a complex model of the human brain that’s understandable. There are also some in philosophy who argue that humans may be cognitively closed off to understanding things like the human brain [0]. They note that humans have biological limits to understanding certain things just like an animal might. For instance, an ant, may have biological limits to its understanding of how certain things work.
What do you think of philosophers who argue of cognitive closure?
[0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_closure_(philosophy) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_closure_(philosoph....
- ddingus 7y agoWe may actually get something similar, perhaps even empirically. And maybe we understand it. Worse, we think we do.
- anonthrowaway2 7y agoIt's possible and extraordinarily unlikely. I think any philosopher who argues that it's _likely_ humans have a biological limitation preventing us from ever understanding the human brain is going to be making some obvious errors. Got any examples to check?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mannykannot 7y agoI actually phrased that statement that way to avoid and speculation about what might be possible, as it would be a distraction from the point I am making. As it happens, I think it is probable that such a model is possible in principle, and also that a complete model would not be understandable (in which case, Bonnini's paradox would apply, but it is not the reason why we currently don't have such a model). With regard to cognitive closure, I think the first sentence of the article you link to is trivially true, but I have yet to find a good argument against physicalism in matters of the mind, and philosophers cannot agree among themselves. I think it is interesting how little attention is said about biology in these arguments (Paul Churchland is one exception.)