4 ms·
We’ve had over 200 years to work things out —slowly. It was pretty much a diaspora of the same mindset throughout with a common language and body of law. Two
by mc32 7y ago
We’ve had over 200 years to work things out —slowly. It was pretty much a diaspora of the same mindset throughout with a common language and body of law.
Two hundred or a hundred years ago people put up with a lot. A modern world doesn’t want to wait for things to work themselves out.
- naravara 7y ago>We’ve had over 200 years to work things out slowly. It was pretty much a diaspora of the same mindset throughout with a common language. Not really. Big parts of Pennsylvania and New York we’re speaking Dutch. A lot of the South was speaking Spanish. A bunch of the hinterland was Francophone. And that’s just the White people.
- mc32 7y agoSo you’re saying the EU should be like an XVIII century formational country like the US or even Russia or China or Japan and homogenize? Maybe let’s start with the French dropping French and let’s have Russia give up some land for eastward expansion. Once you prove your success there, Africa awaits for unification efforts too.
- happymellon 7y agoYou say that like you jest, but with the UK out the chances of having a common language have improved.
- rayiner 7y agoTwo hundred years ago, the federal government was tiny and most decisions were made locally. That changed dramatically in the last two generations.
- mc32 7y agoAbsolutely but it’s been a very slow creep. Not a sudden imposition.
- tptacek 7y agoA "generation" in scientific terms is roughly 25 years, right? In 1969, you couldn't drive a truck full of oranges between cities in two different states without permission from a federal agency, if I understand the history here correctly.
- rayiner 7y agoThere was two big spikes: three generations ago, FDR and WWII caused the federal government to grow from 5% of GDP to 25% of GDP, and dominate economic regulation, and then two generations ago the Warren Court caused the federal government to dominate social regulation. After FDR, but before Warren, you couldn’t drive oranges between states without federal permission, but you could have prayer in local schools conforming to local values. The latter was arguably a bigger destabilizing force than the former.
- tptacek 7y agoSo it seems to me we sorted that out almost exactly the right way. Parents are responsible for inculcating religious values into their kids, not school administrators, and we don't pay $5 for an orange†. Either way: it can't be the case that things were more decentralized and local 2 generations ago and more centralized now, because, well, no, they aren't. † I don't like oranges and haven't bought one in years so if it turns out we do pay $5 for an orange pretend I said $50, which I'm pretty sure we don't pay.
- rayiner 7y agoParents have always relied on the community to help inculcate religious values, just as they do with other kinds of values. Talking religion out of schools, where kids spend most of their waking time, and the public sphere generally, cut the legs out from under a key institution that was integral to the fabric of American society. And in the process it created enormous resentment to the folks who had orchestrated that destruction. Even when you come to the “right” conclusion, imposing rules on people contrary to their values comes at a high price. In Bangladesh, the liberal elite tried to impose ideas like secular government. The common people pushed back, backing a military dictator that made Islam the official religion. 50 years later, the struggle between the two sides continues. You can’t beat people into believing the right things. There is nothing fundamentally different about Americans. You can impose the right answer on issues ranging from abortion to obscenity (and for the most part, I believe we have), but people will resent you for overriding their community’s choices. The cost of correcting injustice is straining the fabric that binds you together. (How much does a banana even cost? $5?)