2 ms·
I'm reminded of the similar tool that could identify sexual orientation from a photo. It only worked on those who fit certain stereotypical behaviors, persons w
by nl 7y ago
I'm reminded of the similar tool that could identify sexual orientation from a photo. It only worked on those who fit certain stereotypical behaviors, persons who actively self-identified as being in a particular category. When tied to immutable characteristics (skull dimensions) it fell apart.
That paper was particularly bad. To a large degree it was a dataset detector (the "gay" and "non-gay" facial datasets came from different sources, based on different geography).
This paper is much more limited in the claims it is making - only that it correlates well on faces that appear white and "Asian", and that it doesn't correlate as well for "Indian" and black. The speculate that this is because of under-representation of those classes.
So the software accurately depicts the race of a person according to what some other software has determined their race to be?
Are you arguing that Face++ is inaccurate? It would surprise me if a machine learning model isn't pretty much as good as humans at this. I don't see any numbers quoted by Face++, but an paper claims 93% accuracy[1]
I cannot wait to see how many L's I need to mispronounce for this thing to assume I'm an Asian from the Bronx
So if you make yourself talk like an "Asian from the Bronx" and it detects that then... it is working, no?
[1] http://www.bernardjjansen.com/uploads/2/4/1/8/24188166/jansen_facial_icwsm2018.pdf http://www.bernardjjansen.com/uploads/2/4/1/8/24188166/janse...