4 ms·
Elon Musk may be a pain, but that doesn’t mean his ideas are crazy
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoThat idea has been floated since as long as self-driving cars became a realistic prospect. People love their cars and consider them a private space. I don't see many people agreeing to let any random person do who knows what in them...
- __d 7y agoSee https://www.carnextdoor.com.au https://www.carnextdoor.com.au for some evidence that there exist people who are perfectly happy to allow random people do who knows what in their cars.
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoOf course "there exists people who will <replace with anything>". The point is that this is marginal. Dedicated taxis will overwhelmingly dominate.
- __d 7y agoWhen I first heard this idea, my feeling was that the set of people willing to share their car is small. I know that my car has my stuff in it, and I'd need to take that out and return it every time I used the car, and that'd suck. But as evidence that the set might be a little larger than I initially thought, I offer an apparently successful business operating today which relies upon people sharing their vehicles. AirBnB might be a useful data point here though. I don't know what the percentage of dedicated vs shared accommodation is there, but it seems likely to be similar for cars?
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoWell, interestingly if the concept became popular it would bankrupt itself through an oversupply of taxis. As for AirBnB, it's mostly a platform for dedicated rentals these days...
- __d 7y ago> Well, interestingly if the concept became popular it would > bankrupt itself through an oversupply of taxis. I'm not sure that'd be the outcome? If many/most people who own a vehicle make it available for shared use, then I guess there'd be price competition. If willingness to offer your vehicle was (a) motivated by price and (b) varied in its degree, you'd presumably hit a point where some people couldn't be bothered, and would withdraw from the system, reducing supply again. There's no real downside to the service provider of having more vehicles available, assuming their systems scale with minimal cost. I guess the question is whether the price point at which people become unwilling to share their vehicles is higher or lower than the cost of capital and maintenance for a dedicated taxi service. Which seems like it's a sufficiently difficult thing to predict that testing it in the market is probably the right answer :-) > As for AirBnB, it's mostly a platform for dedicated > rentals these days... That's my impression too. Which is a data point kinda in favour of the "dedicated" model. I'm not sure how the "tool sharing" businesses are going -- they might be another useful input?
- tlb 7y agoCould regular car owners farm their cars out as regular taxis? It doesn't seem compelling. The only value that car owners are providing in this scenario are capital (the cost of the car) and maintenance. The capital for a self-driving taxi is more than a regular taxi, but otherwise it's similar. Both capital and maintenance can be provided more efficiently in bulk than in a cottage industry model.
- __d 7y agoI agree that the economics here are interesting. I think it's useful to consider firstly car sharing, without the autonomous aspect. I think it's a pretty compelling argument for many car owners whose capital is otherwise tied up in a mostly unproductive asset. Particularly in the case where you end up paying for parking during some of this unproductive time. For the service provider, I think ultimately you're looking at the cost of supplying a vehicle to transport your customer. Where the car is shared, can that cost be lower than if it's a dedicated vehicle? I think it can, because for car owners willing to share, any income is a bonus. It just has to be enough to overcome any inconvenience to make it worthwhile. And I think that's the point that your "cottage industry" comment misses: the costs of capital and maintenance are immaterial to the service provider. All they need to pay to overcome is the inconvenience and any psychological "yuck" factor.