4 ms·
Only if you assume the current population of the city is held steady and you are not beaten out by new arrivals. Every law of basic economics exists only under
by anigbrowl 7y ago
Only if you assume the current population of the city is held steady and you are not beaten out by new arrivals.
Every law of basic economics exists only under very narrow conditions where all but one factor is controlled. Expecting the real world to conform to theoretical models is about as sensible as looking for rocks that happen to be perfect platonic solids. Pointing this out is not a rejection of economics any more than pointing to the variegation of rocks indicates a dislike of geometry.
- foota 7y agoIt would help relative to doing nothing in that case though, right?
- anigbrowl 7y agoI'm honestly not sure. I can't think of arguments both ways but not an easy way to model it.
- nostrademons 7y agoYou can model it effectively by taking dollar values out of the equation and assuming a rank ordering of people who want to live in an area by the amount they are willing & able to spend on housing. If an area has say 1M housing units but 3M people want to live there, only the top 1/3 of people who want to live there will be able to. The market-clearing housing price (or rent) will be whatever that 67th-percentile hopeful has available to spend on housing. Building more housing means you go further down the list of incomes. Fixing income inequality reduces the gap between what the person who gets the house pays and what the person who doesn't get the house would need to pay, which makes things seem more achievable (and increases disposable income for people who get the house), but doesn't change who gets the houses. Rent control replaces the price-ordering by time-and-luck-ordering for a subset of the population: some people enter a secondary housing market where they get the house by virtue of being lucky at the time it went on the market. Prop 13 preferences older homeowners over new immigrants (or young people) by effectively surcharging new purchasers. The only two policies that solve the displacement problem are building more housing and making the city less desirable to residents, but other policies can change who gets displaced. San Francisco is an interesting case because tech tends to have so much higher salaries than other industries. As long as there are enough tech workers to fill up all vacancies in a given housing market, the market-clearing price will rise to a tech-worker's salary, and everyone in other industries will be forced out. How many people can San Francisco tech companies hire? I dunno, but I'd bet it's a lot more than the number of housing units currently being built in SF, which means that some people are gonna get kicked out on the street. The single-family home market in the Bay Area is probably already shot - given the number of units on the market, dual-tech-earner families could easily fill them. But the condo and rental market might be able to be saved; enough building could probably create enough housing there to absorb the tech industry, which would leave units that rent at the price an ordinary worker could afford.
- foota 7y agoThat was great, thanks for the detailed response! I think it might be interesting also to talk about the quality of housing. You touch on a related topic "making the city less desirable to residents", but I think it's worth adding something to that. If you segment the housing by housing deemed good enough by people with high incomes, and housing of a quality which they won't live in, you can achieve the goal of allowing in lower income people without satisfying the demand for all of the higher income people (either high income people won't work and live in the city, or they'll commute from somewhere with housing they want). Additionally, you can lower the threshold for people living in the city to live outside the city by making commutes easier. This could also be used to demonstrate how replacing old and lower quality housing with luxury housing could negatively impact people with lower incomes, even if you're building more luxury units than there were previously low quality units, since in this thought experiment the market for luxury units doesn't affect that for low quality units (this refutes a commonly posed argument that it's good to build luxury housing as long as it's lots of units). I can't say for certain that they market actually segments like this, but it's not too hard to convince yourself that it does.
- jaredklewis 7y ago> Only if you assume the current population of the city is held steady and you are not beaten out by new arrivals. The population does not have to be held steady for the new high-end housing to lower prices for mid and low-end housing. The only assumption the parent makes is that the aggregate desire of people not currently living in SF to move to SF is not affected by the increase in supply. This is an assumption, but I don't think an outlandish one. Yes, of course some of the newly opened mid-level apartments (when their previous inhabitant moves to a high-end apartment) will be filled by new comers. But aren't those new comers going to compete for the existing space whether or not a more high-end space gets built?
- anigbrowl 7y agoTheir decision to move here is probably a function of the (perceived) available housing stock.
- jaredklewis 7y agoHow does that make sense? What about all of the people that have moved to SF in the last few years? Did they come because hey thought there was availability? If availability was a major factor in where people wanted to live, Detroit wouldn’t be half empty. Now if the increase in high end housing makes housing across the board cheaper, then yes, it makes a lot of sense that more people would want to come. Because the plan worked and housing got cheaper.
- marchenko 7y agoPerhaps housing availability is sufficient but not necessary in drawing people to a desirable region, in a manner akin to the idea of induced demand in traffic engineering.
- masonic 7y agobeaten out by new arrivals They don't even have to be "arrivals"; many are foreign investors who don't currently live there.
- conanbatt 7y agoIt has to be made clear: one thing is to worry about price, another one to worry about affordability. If you create more housing, and price stays the same because demand went up, its become more affordable as it is literally allowing more people to live in SF.