57 ms·
>> How would it be possible for building more housing to /not/ work is the real question. Buildings full of giant luxury condos. That would soften the higher e
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> How would it be possible for building more housing to /not/ work is the real question.
Buildings full of giant luxury condos. That would soften the higher end of the market but not address the real affordability crisis. Similarly, mcmansions have very high maintenance costs. Vast tracks of six-bedroom single-family suburban homes wouldn't work either if the people who need housing cannot afford to maintain them. And at a more basic level, creating new owner-occupied housing opportunities only helps those with the credit+capital to purchase them. What is needed to get rents down is more rental properties on the market.
Vancouver is seeing this. The boom over the last few years has created oversupply at the very high end of the market. Houses over $5million aren't selling like they once did. That doesn't do anything for working people looking to rent apartments.
- outlace 7y agoEven if all new construction was luxury apartments and condos it would still help. Right now if you make $120,000/yr in SF as an entry level software developer you might pay $2500/mo for an old one bedroom. If new luxury buildings go up, you might be able to upgrade to a nicer one bedroom for $2500 and now the old one bedroom will be available for someone making $90k/yr and so on.
- sandworm101 7y agoIt would help somewhat but if a city is deciding how to zone a plot of land to best address the housing problem, smaller/cheaper units would be the more efficient route. >> Right now if you make $120,000/yr in SF as an entry level software developer SF's government doesn't care much about those making 100+/year. They are looking at a sea of homeless people. They need/want to address the lower end of the market, apartments for waiters and bus drivers.
- erik_seaberg 7y agoThat's nice but the upmarket shortage is adding to the downmarket (substitute good) shortage. If a techie and a waiter each need an apartment, but the city doesn't permit two apartments to be built, they shouldn't be surprised what happens.
- twblalock 7y agoPeople are moving to San Francisco to take high-paying jobs and there is not enough luxury housing to accommodate them, so they are out-competing poorer people for whatever housing they can get. If more luxury housing was built, those people would take it and leave the rest of the housing for other people.
- sandworm101 7y agoIf the rich people are already willing to live in smaller apartments, let them. I say the city should concentrate on housing the poor and homeless. Let the rich take care of themselves. They generally do.
- sigstoat 7y agoand the point is they'll take care of themselves by renting the cheap housing if that's all thats available. even if the rental cost is fixed, they'll outbid by being better tenants, or hiring agencies to get their name in first on waiting lists, or just bribing the low-level decision makers. build more housing.
- anigbrowl 7y agoOnly if you assume the current population of the city is held steady and you are not beaten out by new arrivals. Every law of basic economics exists only under very narrow conditions where all but one factor is controlled. Expecting the real world to conform to theoretical models is about as sensible as looking for rocks that happen to be perfect platonic solids. Pointing this out is not a rejection of economics any more than pointing to the variegation of rocks indicates a dislike of geometry.
- foota 7y agoIt would help relative to doing nothing in that case though, right?
- anigbrowl 7y agoI'm honestly not sure. I can't think of arguments both ways but not an easy way to model it.
- nostrademons 7y agoYou can model it effectively by taking dollar values out of the equation and assuming a rank ordering of people who want to live in an area by the amount they are willing & able to spend on housing. If an area has say 1M housing units but 3M people want to live there, only the top 1/3 of people who want to live there will be able to. The market-clearing housing price (or rent) will be whatever that 67th-percentile hopeful has available to spend on housing. Building more housing means you go further down the list of incomes. Fixing income inequality reduces the gap between what the person who gets the house pays and what the person who doesn't get the house would need to pay, which makes things seem more achievable (and increases disposable income for people who get the house), but doesn't change who gets the houses. Rent control replaces the price-ordering by time-and-luck-ordering for a subset of the population: some people enter a secondary housing market where they get the house by virtue of being lucky at the time it went on the market. Prop 13 preferences older homeowners over new immigrants (or young people) by effectively surcharging new purchasers. The only two policies that solve the displacement problem are building more housing and making the city less desirable to residents, but other policies can change who gets displaced. San Francisco is an interesting case because tech tends to have so much higher salaries than other industries. As long as there are enough tech workers to fill up all vacancies in a given housing market, the market-clearing price will rise to a tech-worker's salary, and everyone in other industries will be forced out. How many people can San Francisco tech companies hire? I dunno, but I'd bet it's a lot more than the number of housing units currently being built in SF, which means that some people are gonna get kicked out on the street. The single-family home market in the Bay Area is probably already shot - given the number of units on the market, dual-tech-earner families could easily fill them. But the condo and rental market might be able to be saved; enough building could probably create enough housing there to absorb the tech industry, which would leave units that rent at the price an ordinary worker could afford.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- barbecue_sauce 7y agoIsn't there a point after market saturation where a large enough glut of luxury condos just causes their rent to be pushed down into the realm of affordability? (Not a Silicon Valley person, or aspirant).
- sandworm101 7y agoHousing isn't a perfect theoretical commodity like gold or stocks. Every unit has an occupation cost (heat/utilities, commuting costs and such). Every new building must pay for its construction costs, which is tied heavily to interest rates. So there are limits as to how cheap any housing unit can become before it ends up sitting vacant, waiting for the market to catch up with it.
- darksaints 7y agoIt's not necessary to pay for construction costs. That's what bankruptcy is for. Of course developers and banks avoid that as best as possible, but there is nothing stopping price from dropping below the cost of construction. It has happened countless times before and it will happen again.
- fragmede 7y agoFactories want to get paid for producing product, mines digging gold or ore out of the ground want to get paid as well. But, similar to excesses in housing in distressed areas, circa 2008 (maybe Las Vegas?), someone, somewhere lost money, because price is not dependant on the cost of producing the thing. 'Cost plus' pricing strategy is one of many; cost is not the only driver, regardless of the good.
- nostrademons 7y agoBankruptcy. If the market-clearing rent for an area drops below what the developer needs to pay the interest on the construction costs, it doesn't just sit idle (if it does, the developer just goes bankrupt faster). Rather, the developer goes bankrupt, he and the bank both take a haircut, and the property gets sold to a new owner at whatever price the new market-clearing rent can support. The new owner then makes a profit renting at reduced market rates. This happens periodically in the Bay Area - it happened on a large scale in both 2001 and 2009. It's the best time both to make a real estate investment (folks who bought housing in 2010 are sitting pretty now; I'm kicking myself for not) and to be a renter (I rented a lovely apartment for $1400/month for 3 years in 09-11 that had gone for > $2000 in 2007, and is at about $2800 now).
- erik_seaberg 7y ago> Condos are getting built in huge numbers; they all get bought immediately, and for the most part, they’re all lived in. The article made it sound like Toronto doesn't have an oversupply, at best they may have reduced latent demand.
- opportune 7y agoThe simplest answer possible: the higher end of the market, in a market based housing system, will always live where it wants to live, because it can bid up rental prices higher than the rest of the market when there is housing scarcity. Right now in the bay area, there are many wealthy people (including many people on this website) that are living in non-luxury condos that would live in luxury condos were they more reasonably priced (which building more would do). Those wealthy people would move out of middle class housing and then people with lower incomes would be able to afford the middle class housing. If you build enough luxury housing, the greatest beneficiaries will be people with lower incomes
- waste_monk 7y ago>Vast tracks of six-bedroom single-family suburban homes Tracts I hate to be "that guy" but tracks/tracts really bothers me, second only to turrent/turret.
- tcpekin 7y agoWhat is a turrent? Tourette?
- waste_monk 7y agoA common mispronunciation or 'eggcorn' of the word turret.
- closeparen 7y agoHow do you tell a luxury condo from any other kind of condo? - By price? Then all housing in a hot market is luxury, even what everyone would agree is a dump. Wanting to stop development because the market is hot is exactly backwards. - By price relative to the market? New construction is usually more desirable than old construction, today's cheap housing was luxurious when new, and we'd better make more so that there will be cheap housing still standing in 50 years. - By marketing language? Then developers can appease community concerns by changing their brochures a little. - By square feet? That'd be one truly enormous condo to have a square footage that's offensive when compared to a typical house, although I guess it could be what's happening. If the units turn out to be too big for the market, can't they be subdivided later? - By amenities? I can speak from experience that media rooms, demo kitchens, event spaces, etc. are not that exciting and certainly not worth even a few hundred extra per month. Most people would rather go to a real gym. - By interior finishings? Isn't this, like, a few tens of thousands of dollars per unit at the high end? Compared to an overall unit price of $500k+ this doesn't seem like a huge deal. I've always been confused about what this category means and why it's a useful separator of acceptable vs. bad development. >Houses over $5million aren't selling like they once did. That doesn't do anything for working people looking to rent apartments. Do you think we're going to meet demand at $200k without also meeting demand at $4m?
- diffeomorphism 7y agoRather easily. Your arguments are all about having a fuzzy boundary if you introduce a sharp cut-off. Granted, but irrelevant to the topic and divorced from reality in that there is decidedly not a continuum, which is the whole point of offense.
- closeparen 7y agoCould you provide some examples of condos of similar age and location that are clearly so luxurious they shouldn’t exist vs. those that are okay?