4 ms·
> If I shop-lift a screwdriver from home depot and then return it a week later is that stealing? Actually, no. If you intend to return it in the original condi
by philh 16y ago
> If I shop-lift a screwdriver from home depot and then return it a week later is that stealing?
Actually, no. If you intend to return it in the original condition, so they can still sell it, then legally speaking it isn't theft. (It may still be illegal, I don't know.)
Just to clarify, I'm not claiming anything about piracy here.
- HeyLaughingBoy 16y agoSo, if I beat the crap out of you, but take you to the hospital later and pay all your bills, it's OK?
- rprasad 16y agoActually, legally, it is theft. The crime is taking the property from the store without their permission. Whether or not you intend to return in its original condition is beside the point.
- philh 16y ago"A person is guilty of theft, if he dishonestly appropriates property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving the other of it". Actually, I'm not sure that US law is the same. But that's how it is in England.
- rprasad 16y agoThat's close to the "Restatement" (law school) definition of theft in America. In practice, the statutory definitions of theft are far more expansive, and even where they aren't, case law has made the standard for "permanent deprivation" ridiculously low.
- philh 16y agoFair enough. Thanks for the correction.