3 ms·
I agree that is a mostly solved problem. It still seems weird to call nuclear "clean", when the thing you have to obsess over is not leaking one of the deadlie
by paulddraper 7y ago
I agree that is a mostly solved problem.
It still seems weird to call nuclear "clean", when the thing you have to obsess over is not leaking one of the deadliest materials in existence.
But I suppose you could argue it's cleaner than everything else (when considering manufacturing).
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThere's plenty to worry about not leaking in solar too; nothing high-tech is truly clean, especially if you consider manufacturing. Anyways, despite being near-synonymous with "renewable", I always understood "clean" in "clean energy" to mean "doesn't pollute the atmosphere". Nuclear doesn't pollute the atmosphere, so it qualifies. Even if you extend it to "doesn't pollute the environment", nuclear generally doesn't, as the little waste that's produced is stored as a part of the process - as opposed to waste products of traditional fossil fuel plants. Some new reactor designs allow you to further burn the waste, making it almost truly non-polluting in the general sense. In all honesty, like many pro-nuclear people, I do emphasize calling nuclear "clean energy" on purpose, precisely to counter people like 'ThomPete upthread who lump together nuclear with fossil fuels. While still having some (and admittedly dangerous if mishandled) waste, in terms of cleanness, nuclear is really much much closer to solar & wind than it is to coal and gas - it is an ecological source, and grouping it together with fossil sources makes people dismiss one of the more effective ways at generating power in climate-protecting way.
- cesarb 7y ago> and grouping it together with fossil sources makes people dismiss one of the more effective ways at generating power in climate-protecting way. To play devil's advocate, there's a good reason to group nuclear together with fossil fuel sources: both are thermal power plants, they only differ in the source of the heat. In terms of power generation, nuclear is much closer to coal and gas than it is to solar and wind.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThat's fair, but if you want to go this way, you'll end up grouping them together with wind, hydro and concentrated solar, as they're all based on spinning coils around magnets (or the other way around). While this categorization may be useful for some specialized engineering discussions, it's useless when talking about environmental issues. When talking climate, we care about pollution and emissions - both of which put nuclear in the same group as renewables. (The one potential environmental aspect where "thermal plants" as a category is useful is that thermal plants need a heat sink to operate, which usually means a river or a pond. On the scale of climate issues, however, this is a negligible point that I haven't even seen brought up once by anyone.)