5 ms·
So we know that this distribution is bad for the economy, and these trends generally precede a recession or depression. We also know that the policies that fix
by jedberg 7y ago
So we know that this distribution is bad for the economy, and these trends generally precede a recession or depression.
We also know that the policies that fix this, namely a wealth tax and or extremely high taxes on the wealthy generally don't produce the results you want (the ultra-rich tend to find ways to avoid said taxes so only the minor-rich end up paying).
So what do we do?
- krsrhe 7y agoWe do nothing special, and have a recession/depression cycle.
- jedberg 7y agoPeople tend to die during those events due to lack of access to food and health care. So that may not be the best solution.
- jdavis703 7y agoMake the tax code simpler. Eliminate all deductions. Have the government distribute grants for R&D, home ownership, childrearing or whatever other behaviors they want to incentivize — there’s no reason all these programs need to be administered by the IRS.
- cm2012 7y agoI'm pretty sure that higher taxes in general do reduce inequality. Inequality is far smaller in Europe than in the US, smaller still in Scandinavia.
- jopsen 7y agoIt's also what you do with the taxes..
- zanny 7y agoBarring legislative capture by the rich (which happens a lot because of their distortedly large influence) just taking money out of their pockets does a lot to remedy a lot of the negative consequences of such high inequality. They could tax the rich, straight pay off federal debt obligations, and society would be healthier for it. Wealth inequality is more about the influence money has in both micro and macro-economic and social contexts than "I want what they have". Its no different than how other monopolizations work - the more of a supply you hold, the more distorted the market is around you. The same applies to money. Except money impacts all aspects of society, all markets - it gives you a greater voice in government, gives you influence over the lives of upwards of billions of people, etc. Just taking away that power from private individuals is often by itself a net positive for liberty.
- User23 7y agoThis is caused by at least two things. First, as noted, crushing the little rich with high taxes. Second, the ultra rich just hide their money (funny how everyone memory-holed the Panama Papers) so it doesn't show up in the figures and count toward inequality. US mega-rich have less incentive to hide their money, in fact some US states are seen as tax havens, so the figures here are more honest. Also, there are European countries like Germany with an income distribution pretty close to the US.
- bwb 7y agoYep, but IMO Germany has done a better job of controlling major costs which leads to less stress, ie housing and health care are much lower costs there IMO.
- sadris 7y agoThere is less cognitive ability diversity in Scandinavia than the US. Given the extreme correlation between intelligence and workplace performance, it would be expected in a locality with high levels of variance in intelligence.
- itronitron 7y agoI'm not so sure that there is less cognitive ability diversity in Scandinavia, given this >> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Nordic_Biker_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Nordic_Biker_War
- throwawaysea 7y agoWhy do you think such distributions generally precede a recession or depression? I don’t see the causality here as clearly as say a yield curve inversion. And follow-up, why is that bad instead of just expected? People have more purchasing power and access to goods/services than ever before. Perhaps the relative ubiquity of smartphones is the most emblematic sign of this. Put another way, things are better than they’ve ever been and even in the last ten years, quality of life has improved in many ways. So is there really a problem?
- calcifer 7y ago> things are better than they’ve ever been [...] So is there really a problem? That's begging the question. Things are better for you, but is the improvement across the board or did the rich getting richer screwed over some people and made them even poorer?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kjar 7y agoThis argument is laughable. We all have smartphones so serious wealth inequality is OK? These days having a phone is a near requirement.
- throwawaysea 7y agoHow is it a requirement? I have friends that don’t have a smartphone as well. Or cable. Or Netflix. And yet lots of people who seem upset at the state of things happily spend on all these same unnecessary goods and services. If anything it points to the fact that these things are more important to them than things people are claiming are necessities or “rights”, such as healthcare.
- throwawaymath 7y agoI don't have a comment on inequality generally, but what's your point specifically about a phone being a requirement? Toilets are also a "near requirement" in any meaningful sense that phones are a near requirement. But toilets (and sewage more generally) are obviously quality of life improvements over what humans had in previous epochs of history. Stated more succinctly: hasn't it always been common for major improvements in quality of life to eventually become the default, rather than the exception? Or am I misunderstanding your point?
- preommr 7y agoStart with things like better voter rights and then hold politicians accountable. I constantly see companies breaking rules and getting hit with paltry fines. And this happens for a bunch of reasons but one of them is that a lot of politicians don't bother chasing after these things because the companies drag them out and put out enough spin that it doesn't become worthwhile for punishment to be given such that the behavior is stopped.
- AlexTWithBeard 7y agoWhich exact voting rights are missing at the moment?
- TAForObvReasons 7y agoThe ability to vote? When a state decides to close down numerous polling places, it increases the burden to vote. People at some places had to wait 2 or more hours on line to vote, and that's disenfranchising. You may technically have a right to vote, but if the government puts up too many roadblocks it's in practice a prohibition
- AlexTWithBeard 7y agoOpening more polling place will increase the number of voters, but I'm afraid won't increase the quality: new stream of voters will be as prone to demagoguery and rhetorics as existing ones.
- TAForObvReasons 7y agoThat's a complete non-sequitur. Your question was: > Which exact voting rights are missing at the moment? And the answer, as reported in various places, is that the right to vote is for all intents and purposes non-existent for people in certain areas. Voter disenfranchisement is a real and documented thing. Polling places are shutting down, which puts an undue burden on people who don't have the luxury of taking the day off or getting out of work early. You might appreciate a tech example: if Facebook doesn't actually remove all of your data, just "deactivating your account" while keeping the data stored on their servers, do you really have the option to opt out of Facebook?
- cmurf 7y agoTop tax bracket increase. For 40 years the top tax bracket was not less than 70% and for 10 years in that time the top tax bracket was not less than 90%. Basically, don't be a hoarder. If you really think you can spend your money better than the government, grow or start a business and take a tax deduction which will permit you to avoid the tax. And in that same time period, most people did that. The incentive worked. Not many people paid 90% rates. And the U.S. middle class wage growth was the envy of the world, it was the world's largest creditor nation, and we built massive amounts of private and public infrastructure. But then we reverted to a neo-feudal and prosperity theology model. People either have to understand these things, and understand that voting matters, or the inequality will get worse and at a certain point civil society will break. It's automatic. Violence is the most successful corrector of wealth inequality humans have yet invented. Rational liberal types keep wanting to build something different, but plutocratic illiberals keep successfully convincing just enough people that being a hoarder has merit, is a right, or brings you closer to a deity, etc. These are very old ideas, it's all very old history, none of it is original.
- jedberg 7y agoI'm aware that the top tax rate was that high, and as you correctly note, almost no one paid that rate. But that's not because they were starting businesses. It's because they lobbied for a ton of loopholes in the tax code. The ultra-rich will stay ultra-rich through regulatory capture. Sometimes the mini-rich will benefit as a side effect.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> For 40 years the top tax bracket was not less than 70% and for 10 years in that time the top tax bracket was not less than 90%. During the times when those rates were in effect there were so many deductions that nobody with an accountant actually paid them. It wasn't just that business expenses were deductions, people were deducting their homes and personal vehicles and everything. > Basically, don't be a hoarder. If you really think you can spend your money better than the government, grow or start a business and take a tax deduction which will permit you to avoid the tax. That is the exact thing the rich do already, which is why wealth inequality continues to increase -- if you make money and use it to grow your business (which is a tax deduction) then you make even more money, which you then use to grow your business... The canonical example of doing this is probably Amazon, a company that for years made no "profit" not because it was hiding it offshore but because it was reinvesting it all. Which at one point had the highest market cap of any company and is still in the top three, and Bezos is the richest man. But that's not even the biggest reason for the increase in wealth inequality we've seen. It's the cheap credit. If you lower interest rates for years, people are willing to borrow more which inflates asset prices. Then people are forced to pay interest on money they otherwise wouldn't have had to borrow to begin with in order to pay the higher cost of housing and education, meanwhile stock prices increase because demand there is driven by people borrowing too. The result is that ordinary people have to borrow money and pay interest just to live, which reduces their wealth, meanwhile the borrowing-driven demand increases the value of assets already owned by the wealthy, which increases their wealth. To fix this, interest rates have to increase. And then there are two options. The first is that housing and stock prices crash as people sell to pay back the loans they can't afford at the higher interest rates. The second is that we raise interest rates while printing enough money to cause inflation sufficient to offset the reduction in asset values, which effectively leaves housing and stock prices where they are but allows for non-asset inflation (i.e. allows wages to rise) to catch up with them. Bonus points if the printed money funds a UBI.
- jopsen 7y ago[citation needed] You don't fix this through income redistribution. You fix it by offering free/cheap education, healthcare, etc. this generally requires taxes and, yes, the wealthiest should bear the most. But it's not about taking from the rich and giving to the poor. It's about creating opportunities for the poor.
- jedberg 7y ago> You fix it by offering free/cheap education, healthcare, etc. That's just income redistribution with a middle man. To be clear, I'm all for those things and I think they will help, but don't pretend it's not income redistribution, which mostly hits the mini-rich and not the ultra-rich.
- jopsen 7y agoYes, it's also redistribution -- but you redistribute a very small part to get growth which is what does the trick...