5 ms·
FreeBSD/EC2 lives
- eddanger 16y agoI've been waiting for this for years! Amazon EC2 might have just jumped from a being novelty to something useful! (for me at least)
- cperciva 16y agoI'd recommend waiting for some more bugs to be worked out before you start using this in production -- but please feel free to start launching instances and helping me find said bugs. :-)
- eddanger 16y agoIndeed. Thanks for all your hard work, an impressive feat. You guys are unsung heroes in a world where we expect things to "just work".
- Dobbs 16y agoThanks so much Colin. I'll probably be switching my play linode over to ec2.
- Ixiaus 16y agoGreat work Colin! I'm definitely going to jump on the free usage tier and experiment with it. I've been holding out, entirely, for FreeBSD to come to EC2.
- gonzo 16y agovery, very cool
- dazzawazza 16y agoThanks for this. As a long term FreeBSD user it's great to have more platforms to deploy on.
- tibbon 16y agoWait what? I thought that Netcraft has confirmed: *BSD is dying
- Ixiaus 16y agoDying? That may be true of the other BSD's but FreeBSD appears to be thriving; some very big companies, universities, &c... use and rely on FreeBSD. OpenBSD appears to be alive and well too, but from my perspective FreeBSD tends to have the spotlight.
- lincolnq 16y agoHe's not serious. It's a classic Slashdot troll.
- sgt 16y agoDefinitely not dying. In fact I think FreeBSD will just increase in popularity in the years to come. It had a bit of a dip in the last 3-4 years, but even from that it has shown how well the project holds up.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- grammaton 16y agoYhea, that must be why they're able to find contributers to do things like paravirtualize it. Because it's dying....
- pan69 16y agoI hope Linode and Slicehost follow soon. We could use more low cost *BSD virtualization.
- carson 16y agoLinode has actually been able to do NetBSD for a while: http://www.linode.com/wiki/index.php/NetBSD_howto http://www.linode.com/wiki/index.php/NetBSD_howto With a little work I'm sure this version of FreeBSD can be installed on Linode as well.
- wwortiz 16y agoFreeBSD is kind of another beast at this point in time, NetBSD support for xen is actually okay and it is pretty trivial to get it working, freebsd not so much. Hopefully cperciva's work will pay off soon for a stable freebsd on Xen as I know there are plenty of users, me included, that would love this option. Edit: and that linode post on how to get it running looks a bit dated
- ams6110 16y agohttp://www.rootbsd.net/ http://www.rootbsd.net/ is another choice. I'm happy with them.
- cmer 16y agoWhat are the benefits of BSD vs Linux? I could never quite understand why people would chose BSD, but that's likely just ignorance.
- shin_lao 16y agoOne could turn the tables around and wonder why people would chose Linux over BSD. To me the biggest advantage is that BSD is fully integrated (it's a full system, not just a kernel) and there are compatibility guarantees. For example a binary built for 8.0 will stay compatible with the whole 8.x series.
- _delirium 16y ago> BSD is fully integrated (it's a full system, not just a kernel) and there are compatibility guarantees. That's true of Debian, too, though. We can disagree on which project does a better job at it, but they're both full systems, compatibility tested and with long-term support for stable releases.
- burgerbrain 16y agoIt's not true in the same way. Debian and GNU are two separate projects for instance, but Debian relies on the GNU userland. Same goes with the kernel obviously, and numerous other projects. The BSD projects however (for the most part) do all their own code, all under a single source tree. The merits of each method are up for debate, however they are pretty distinct.
- burgerbrain 16y agoMight also be worth noting that Debian's disregard of the upstream (compared to say Fedora, which makes an effort to get patches into the upstream before using them), has gotten them into trouble on a few occasions. The most prominent in recent time being their absolutely braindead patching of OpenSSL which dramatically reduced the entropy in key generation, which would have never made it through the peer review process of the upstream... Debian likes to think that they are the upstream of the projects they use, but unlike the BSDs they really are not.
- tshtf 16y agoColin, excellent! BTW, how should we file bugs if/when we find them?
- cperciva 16y agoSubmit FreeBSD PRs or send me email -- or ideally both.
- comice 16y ago[self-promote]: We at Brightbox have had FreeBSD 8.1+ support for a few weeks now: http://blog.brightbox.co.uk/posts/freebsd-cloud http://blog.brightbox.co.uk/posts/freebsd-cloud
- shin_lao 16y agoI'd love to use a FreeBSD provider, but your page takes years to load. That's not the best promotion you can come up with, is it?
- comice 16y agoWe have a "sleep 3.years if user == 'shin_lao'" in there.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- X-Istence 16y agoI got my beta key for you guys today! Awesome. Will have to give it a good spin!
- jonhohle 16y agoI've been looking for a way to move off of Joyent shared (solaris) and onto EC2 with FreeBSD for quite some time. This is awesome news. I honestly didn't know if this day would ever come.
- sullrich 16y agoThis is really great news. Thanks a lot Colin and other FreeBSD devs!
- listic 16y agoCongratulations! Could you explain in layman's terms, where did the difficulties lie in using FreeBSD on EC2? Since I think I heard an announcement that FreeBSD 8 supports Xen domU, though I can't find any information to this effect now and FreeBSD Handbook doesn't mention it either: http://www.freebsd.org/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/books/handbook/virtualization-guest.html http://www.freebsd.org/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/books/handbook/vi...
- cperciva 16y agoFreeBSD's paravirtualized Xen support was a pile of crap. EC2 also had some minor quirks which I can't talk about (NDA).
- jeremyjarvis 16y agoWait, you're under an NDA from Amazon? :s
- X-Istence 16y agoYes, unlike the OpenBSD guys, the FreeBSD guys don't mind being under NDA if it means they can release support for hardware sooner rather than later. Look at Sam Leffler and the ath driver (although he is no longer under NDA)
- cperciva 16y agoI don't mind NDAs as long as they're reasonable and I get something out of signing them. In general I'd rather know things and not be able to talk about them than not know in the first place. As FreeBSD security officer I handle 'do not disclose until date X' information on a regular basis.
- listic 16y agoShould I be able to use FreeBSD on Spot Instances? I'm more interested in this for the future, when larger instance types will be available, but still. Looks like I can't use any of the Community AMIs on Spot Instances at the moment. Update: Yes, I can run ami-c01aeca9 on us-east as a Spot Instance! Though any other Community AMI I tried (e.g. Turnkey Linux AMIs) refused to work for me. Any comment on this is still welcome.
- ifdnrg 16y agoits quick to get a usable instance running, to get a usable ports tree, csup -L 2 -h cvsup.FreeBSD.org /usr/share/examples/cvsup/ports-supfile looking forward to seeing stable on here
- gry 16y agoThank you. I've heard fantastic things about FreeBSD for a while now, and now in combination with the micro instances, I can learn and experiment. My EC2 playground is already ported over to FreeBSD, portsnap updated, extracted with a fresh nginx install. It's been a pleasure to use thus far. Thank you, again, Colin.
- wunki 16y agoThanks Colin! You made my day. Is there anything I can do to make this available to EU-West? Or should I just wait?
- cperciva 16y agoWhy do you need this in EU-West? I'm planning on building AMIs for the other regions once this is more production-ready, but at the moment I can't see why it would matter which region it's in.
- grammaton 16y agoOh, this just made my week. I can't wait to get my free tiny instance and start playing with my shiny new toy. I cut my Unix teeth on FreeBSD, and hearing that it's well on it's way into the cloud...well, frankly, I just squeeed a bit inside... Thanks, Colin. A lot of people owe you a beer.