3 ms·
So market driven. So incentive-based. So flat. So American. America loves to do things via tax code, which is why the US tax code is famously so complicated
by sandworm101 7y ago
So market driven. So incentive-based. So flat. So American.
America loves to do things via tax code, which is why the US tax code is famously so complicated, but that time is gone. The answer isn't a new tax to nudge the market. The answer is not an incentive to please stop polluting. We don't need 10% reductions here and there. We need massive reductions everywhere, preferably with active capture that pushes carbon emissions into negative territory. We cannot afford to fund green energy by taxing non-green energy. Coal cannot fund solar. Coal has to stop. We need rules to say that burning coal is now illegal. We need rules that mandate solar+wind as a fixed percentage of energy generation. We need massive rewrites to the rules that limit the deployment of new nuclear technologies. The opportunity for politically-friendly market-based (ie American) approaches has passed. It is time for governments to pass absolute rules forbidding some behaviors and mandating others. If that offends political sensibilities, those political sensibilities need to be set aside.
(1) Burning more than 100kg of coal per year is illegal.
(2) All new houses must include 10m2 of solar panels per resident.
(3) Windmills are, by law, not "an eyesore". No more complaining about them spoiling your retirement view.
(4) Those who cannot articulate the difference between a millisievert and a microsievert, between fission and fusion, are not allowed anywhere near the planning meeting for any new power plant.
- joshe 7y agoIncentives work really really well. Almost nothing else does over the long term. For a concrete alternative with incentives: https://citizensclimatelobby.org/basics-carbon-fee-dividend/ https://citizensclimatelobby.org/basics-carbon-fee-dividend/ A massive $600 billion dollar per year incentive based nudge.
- sandworm101 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal_Protocol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal_Protocol : absolute ban on CFCs worked. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead : EPA mandated reductions of lead in gasoline worked. Not to mention the thousands of little things (drunk driving, slavery, universal suffrage, speed limits etc) that were overturned relatively successfully without any market-based approaches. There is a right-wing philosophy that all government actions are inherently inefficient, but the reality is that laws work. It is possible to ban a behavior on day one and see it substantially reduced on day two.
- thebooktocome 7y agoChina has continued to leak CFCs despite the ban.
- wcoenen 7y agoCFCs in the atmosphere are still dropping. (The news was that the rate at which CFCs disappear has slowed down a bit, and some are pointing at China for that.) I'd say the policy was pretty effective.
- thebooktocome 7y agoI don't think China deserves the benefit of the doubt on this topic. "From the Korean and Japanese data, we used our models to show that emissions of CFC-11 from north eastern China had increased by around 7,000 tons per year after 2013, particularly in or around the provinces of Shandong and Hebei," said Luke Western, a University of Bristol atmospheric modeler. "We didn't find evidence of increasing emissions from Japan, the Korean peninsula or any other country to which our networks are sensitive." https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/22/health/china-cfc-pollution-environment-intl-scn/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/22/health/china-cfc-pollution-en...
- wcoenen 7y agoOK, the emissions were indeed confirmed to be coming from China. Fortunately they are tracking down the CFC producers now and shutting them down: https://nationalpost.com/news/world/china-makes-arrests-shuts-down-rogue-chemical-factories-that-spewed-banned-ozone-depleting-gas?fbclid=IwAR2D_XkH2BtI20r1AeessWBVp8uMXyIWpe5L4wQ1FZAPaWUreQjuwoszVU4 https://nationalpost.com/news/world/china-makes-arrests-shut...
- kortilla 7y agoThere are substitutes for CFCs and leaded gas. The switch was trivial for the majority of the population. Drunk driving is still not solved, and Uber/Lyft have done more to reduce drunk driving in huge parts of the US with poor public transportation than harsher penalties. Laws outright banning things don’t work when a huge chunk of the population will do it anyway. See, prohibition, the war on drugs, etc. Incentivize alternatives, don’t ban without a replacement. Otherwise it will just disrupt and get overturned a few years later.
- brightball 7y agoMarket based approaches work. The only way you’ll ever see wide spread support for them is if they are uniformly applied to companies based in other countries doing business in the US. Anything that puts solely US based companies at a competitive disadvantage is going to be met with opposition.
- empath75 7y agoHow are you proposing to enact and enforce such laws which will surely cause great economic short term harm and will be tremendously unpopular?
- sandworm101 7y agoThe same way they created income tax. Not every law must be popular. How about this: The top US tax rate in the 50s was over 90%. That's a good number for the upper bracket of a progressive carbon tax. In short, large companies are no longer allowed to make profits while emitting carbon. They can continue to operate, but as investment vehicles they will be dead.
- kortilla 7y ago>The top US tax rate in the 50s was over 90%. Yep, but the effective rate was similar to today because of so many deductions. Also, what is a “large company”? I would rather Tesla makes a profit despite it emitting carbon and some small coal power not be allowed to profit just because it only employs 300 people. Just tax carbon output, don’t create all of these half-baked rules trying to punish companies for being large rather than trying to solve the solution of CO2 output.
- ThrustVectoring 7y agoMandating the use of specific technology is uhh, not a great plan over the long run. What happens when photovoltaic is no longer the best way to improve the energy efficiency of roofs? Directly heating water for domestic use is already arguably better than photovoltaic.
- sandworm101 7y agoWe revisit the law. Perfection cannot be the enemy of the good. A standard tactic to oppose any new regulation is to show how it might not be perfect in certain circumstances. That draws out the debate. Draw debate out long enough and the proposed law dies. If solar+wind+nuclear is no longer the best approach in ten years, we can cross that bridge when we come to it.
- kortilla 7y agoNope, you just don’t pass such a shitty law in the first place. You don’t legislate solutions, you legislate results.
- whatshisface 7y agoThe motivation behind using incentives instead of a ban is that there is a desire to lessen the pain of switching away from fossil fuels. Most people on HN could withstand maybe even an 8x increase in the cost of food, transportation and consumer goods without losing anything beyond the superficial (after all in SV the most expensive thing is rent on houses that have already been built). It would be virtually impossible to ruin HN-ers by banning carbon. However, there are people who are very sensitive to prices. They are hurt by trade wars and government interventions into the market's fairly efficient serivce of their basic needs. They are... the poor and lower middle class.
- kortilla 7y agoYawn, this idea of legislating process instead of taxing/punishing outcomes is so much worse because they always backfire when they meet people with incentives. >(1) Burning more than 100kg of coal per year is illegal. No problem, we’ll just burn bunker fuel instead, or 1000kg of wood. Too bad you didn’t just limit carbon instead. >(2) All new houses must include 10m2 of solar panels per resident. Nice, a tax on the poor to force a rollout of an energy source with no baseload story that won’t work on a huge chunk of homes due to location and/or orientation. Solution here is to obviously pick the cheapest possible thing that qualifies as a solar panel. Too bad you didn’t incentivize energy generation. >(3) Windmills are, by law, not "an eyesore". No more complaining about them spoiling your retirement view. This is a joke right? Legislating speech around the appearance of a pervasive man-made object? That’s as dumb as “CO2 is, by law, not ‘a problem’. No more complaining about it risking our future.” The best way to get people to talk about how ugly they are is to ban talking about how ugly they are. >(4) Those who cannot articulate the difference between a millisievert and a microsievert, between fission and fusion, are not allowed anywhere near the planning meeting for any new power plant. This sounds good on paper, but it’s the politicians that hold the ropes here and they are ignorant and listen to the populace. This is why things like the green new deal exclude nuclear energy and effectively accept fossil fuels as base-load by doing so. Politicians cater to their base, not what is right for society or what is logical.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> America loves to do things via tax code, which is why the US tax code is famously so complicated This is true for all democracies.
- perfunctory 7y ago> We need massive rewrites to the rules that limit the deployment of new nuclear technologies. I am not sure rules is what holding nuclear back. Here is an interesting comment https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2SXxJWUv-x4&t=77m59s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2SXxJWUv-x4&t=77m59s