6 ms·
Anecdote. May be untrue. Don't trust everything you read online, etc. A friend was a 7 year Ericsson employee (ending in 2012). In his opinion, Ericsson's netw
by nailer 7y ago
Anecdote. May be untrue. Don't trust everything you read online, etc.
A friend was a 7 year Ericsson employee (ending in 2012). In his opinion, Ericsson's networking equipment was universally acknowledged as having slow deployment times. Nokia's stuff was much faster to deploy. When Huawei hired the ex-Nokia engineers at 2.5x their previous salary, they asked them how Nokia did particular tasks. The engineer would say 'The best way of doing this is...' and get cut off: 'we want to know exactly how Nokia does this, not anything different'. All the Nokia customers moved to Huawei's kit. After a couple of years of extraction Huawei would fire the ex-Nokia engineer saying 'we have everything we need from you'.
Again, might be bullshit.
- alexro 7y agoIf we follow this logic rigorously, how then to explain that Huawei is actually got some of the best smartphones and other products not found across the competitors?
- nailer 7y ago- Weird sudden downward moderation of a previously highly voted comment that is mildly critical of a Chinese company. - Response which doesn't seem to understand the post it is responding to. - Response is in broken English. I think I know what's going on here.
- johnchristopher 7y agoI remember reading an article about how a Chinese company would hire European bakers to demonstrate how they bake breads ad nauseum until they could reproduce and automate each steps perfectly. The thinking was "they [chinese] have no imagination so they stick to known processes and don't deviate". Don't really know what to make of that.
- late2part 7y agoWhich is why this trope about China ruling the world is crap. Generally speaking they are good at copying, reverse engineering, and cheap labor. The country's MO is to steal designs and process and implement better. When the west finally figures out how to stop letting China steal/copy - then the West will continue innovating, and China won't have anything to make.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoExcept the same empty arguments were made against Japan, and were levelled against the nations producing the imported cotton cloth that people were starting to buy in preference to long established Lancashire cotton mills. "Don't buy Japanese electronics or motorcycles, they only make poor cheap copies" would be commonly heard in the seventies and early eighties. They easily - and quickly - moved past that phase, as will China. They mostly already have. In each case the complaining nations have been happy to supply tooling and equipment to enable this.
- HillaryBriss 7y agobut Japan doesn't rule the world
- dfrage 7y agoI absolutely don't know anyone who was saying that about Japanese electronics in the 1970s in my part of US flyover country. Sony was considered to be one of the very best in the world, and my family was greatly disappointed in the 1980s when Sony moved a lot of manufacturing to Mexico and they had to fix many cold solder joints on TV sets. If you wanted a good reel to reel tape deck, Teac was your first choice. One thing left out of this formulation is that it was realized at some point, certainly by the 1970s for electronics, that the Japanese added "and improve", which no one says about the Chinese. Who are said to have a pattern more than a century old of steadily decreasing quality until the customer complains. Different culture, vastly different societal trust levels, Japan high, China low, different results.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoMaybe US experience was different - I certainly remember that impression through the seventies, and the reputation mainly being with the Euro makes - Dual, Grundig, Quad, Tannoy etc. Sony TV had reputation for poor colour. I think they modified their NTSC designs to PAL, or shared something with the US standard. Enough to be noticed by customers anyway. That reputation stuck around a while, but was fading when Walkman arrived (early 80s?), and by the end of the decade they had a solid reputation among the best TVs. Couldn't tell you when they adopted PAL "properly". By the end of the 80s, Japanese makes had cornered the mass market, and were chipping away at the higher end, and many of the Euro brands fading, or disappearing.
- freeflight 7y agoI see it much more in the context of imitation being the sincerest form of flattery. Do you want to know how good authentic European bread is made? You ask European bakers to show it to you and then replicate. Accusing a whole people of a "lack of imagination" is way too reductive a statement. Case in point: I'm sure Chinese noodle-makers could show European cooks a trick or two, just like Europeans stole a trick or two about porcelain making from the Chinese.
- chillacy 7y agoI think historically that was true: at various points in history knowledge of pottery, silk making, literal tea plants and silk worms were “stolen” from China. I’m sure the current leadership remembers those lessons.
- ahelwer 7y agoWhat to make of that is it's a racist belief that Western people hide behind to convince themselves that sure, Chinese people might be smarter, but it's a rote-memorization non-creative type of intelligence and China will never be a leader. They're wrong, and they'll be blindsided by their own racist underestimation.
- chillacy 7y agoI visited the Toyota factory in japan and they talked about how they imported a Chevrolet car and took it apart to replicate it to get started. Then there’s Japanese whisky, denim, music, etc... all extremely high end now.