3 ms·
There seems to me to be a missing step there; I don't get how mirror bacteria somehow automatically hoover up all the resources. They'd be in competition with t
by jerf 16y ago
There seems to me to be a missing step there; I don't get how mirror bacteria somehow automatically hoover up all the resources. They'd be in competition with the normal bacteria, and it is not immediately obvious to me why they so automatically win. Because, again, this is a mirror competition, so whatever putative advantage the flipped version has, the normal version has, along with overwhelming starter advantage. It seems to me there's only really two possible resulting outcomes, based on symmetry arguments: The flipped versions still die out, because life favors the already-dominant hand for some reason, or they compete themselves into a 50/50 standoff because the forces don't favor either side once they reach parity. Life favoring the side with the numerical advantage and crushing the other side also happens to explain why we have one-handed life, so arguably it's the dominant hypothesis at the moment, too, though I wouldn't care to bet the fate of the planet on it.
Now, the bad thing about the 50/50 case is that it may be a much, much lower-energy biosphere, because now all life has to deal with the existence of proteins it can't do anything with and absolutely nothing is evolved to deal with. Could still be a holocaust of epic proportions with the biosphere not really recovering for several million years and almost all non-directly-photosynthesizing life wiped out by starvation as the biosphere has to rebuild from the bottom. (And by "biosphere recovering" I still mean that we're basically wiped back to the Great Oxygenation Event [1] in complexity terms, assuming there's nothing we can do to fix it after the fact.) Could be a disaster, certainly. But I still don't get the claim that it would somehow automatically utterly outcompete the existing biosphere.
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event
- memetichazard 16y agoWouldn't life favor the flipped version because it has no natural predators? Consider it an invasive species [1], something there are many examples of and usually a serious problem. While life may favour existing right-handed life over developing left-handed life, this does not mean it will favor existing right-handed life over developed left-handed life - the argument is akin to saying that an invasive species cannot dominate because it hasn't evolved into place already. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasive_species http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasive_species
- jerf 16y agoAh, yes, maybe that is what I'm missing. Mentally I have a hard time seeing bacteria as something that can be preyed upon, but there's nothing impossible about that, of course, what with the way it happens and all. (Like so many "tipping point"-type arguments my gut still says that if there wasn't an advantage to having us all on the same hand, particularly the ability to pick up correctly-handed molecules out of the environment and use them, that we'd already live in a 50-50 world; if the system is that vulnerable to tipping it would already be tipped, so a small dribbling of cyanobacteria in the ocean will probably simply result in the mirrors dying off. If life is as easy to start up as it seems to be, it seems like at least once a mirror life form should have started up. But that's a plausible line of reasoning, not anything like a proof.)