7 ms·
the cost of complying with the German legal requirements is probably much lower than losing 80 million, very wealthy users. And also regardless of what one's o
by Barrin92 7y ago
the cost of complying with the German legal requirements is probably much lower than losing 80 million, very wealthy users.
And also regardless of what one's opinion about the law is, I'd be sceptical about the idea of a company arbitrarily cancelling service provision to an entire nation because they disagree with a domestic law.
- walterbell 7y agoHow would a company enforce the behavior of open-source client applications on millions of endpoints? If they can't comply with the law, they would be forced to stop service.
- Barrin92 7y agoI don't think they could, these backdoor requests pretty much only apply to companies that have control over the client and server and can break the encryption if they want to. (after all anybody could theoretically already encrypt messages beforehand anyway) I assume whatsapp could provide an api and an open source client but then again they've got a strong commercial incentive to keep it walled in. And anyway, how many users would really switch to a third party client only for encryption? I figure these laws will be relatively effective in practise.
- walterbell 7y agoThere has been a shift in public awareness of surveillance, within the last decade. The adoption of Signal (whose messaging protocol has influenced Whatsapp) shows that some users, including high-value targets, have moved to 3rd-party open-source clients. If the goal is mass surveillance, then it would be enough to backdoor Whatsapp. But if the goal is to target a semi-competent adversary who can use a search engine, such a law would be entirely non-effective. There are existing laws for targeting of data from specific endpoints, e.g. via iCloud, Google. Some of these laws span multiple countries. They cover data from many apps, not just messaging.