3 ms·
I assume the implicit goal here isn't really "disabling features" like private messaging, but rather replacing age-gating in apps like Steam that stand between
by derefr 7y ago
I assume the implicit goal here isn't really "disabling features" like private messaging, but rather replacing age-gating in apps like Steam that stand between a non-logged-in user and the landing page for a rated-M game. (Or, maybe for the first time ever, actually effectively preventing a five-year-old from accessing a porn site just because the porn site doesn't want to be party to showing a five-year-old porn, rather than because the parents installed a content blocker.)
But—possibly-dystopian question here—could this be used in the opposite direction? To keep adults out of safe-space-for-children communities (like the now-defunct Club Penguin)? "Prove you're not an adult" instead of "prove you're not a robot"?
- gizmo686 7y agoI can't imagine a usecase for such a feature. It would prevent parents from auditing the page.
- derefr 7y agoIt would be just as easy to allow adults only read-only access, without allowing them the ability to comment. This would solve e.g. the Elsagate thing. "YouTube Kids" video? Adults can't be creepy in the comments, because adults can't even post in the comments.
- curryst 7y agoI think there are two use cases: the first is a naive "to prevent pedophiles from having access to children". If you don't think too critically about it, I can understand the enthusiasm for it. The second, and I think potentially more legitimate, is to offer children a space to socialize with their peers without having to worry about parental investigation. Whether or not you agree with the parenting style, it's an underserved market segment. A side benefit could be having your juvenile social media sealed somewhat like juvenile criminal records. Something like offering you the option when you turn 18 to delete your profile, or archive it with read-only access to those over 18. Legally, I think it would face troubles in some countries, but countries with laws granting more self-determination to minors might make it a useful environment for exploring ideas with your peers without constant fear that someone may now, or in the future, be offended by your teenage-angst fueled rants. I know I would have enjoyed that, I had a constant fear of retribution through highschool that prevented me from significantly engaging in social media. It wasn't particularly out of line, the usual "my parents suck, my school sucks, let me be a poorly adjusted adult right now!" kind of thing. But I also grew up during the start of the "social media is forever" age, where it started to be common for years-old social media posts by celebrities to become common. And the posts are always judged by today; not the person you were then, or the environment you were in. Frankly I still maintain very little social media presence. I would love to interact with people like that, but I also know that all it takes is one slip-up or vaguely phrased statement to sink you anymore. I like that this might be am opportunity to let kids be kids, and say the darndest thing; but still allow them to be full-fledged members of an online and in-person community without fear that their half-baked childhood ideas might ruin their future.
- dngray 7y agoI think the purpose is advertising targeting kids disguised as child safety. > KidSwitch works by evaluating a number of signals in a content session (gesture patterns, content interaction, hardware inputs etc). These are all the sorts of things that advertising platforms already do. > Prove you're not an adult" And I think any machine learning based on that is a false sense of security. Kids are humans and there's nothing inherently unique about them that distinguishes them reliably from adults enough to not have a by-pass feature. I would bet an adult who wants to "fool" the system would be capable of doing so.
- mirimir 7y ago> But—possibly-dystopian question here—could this be used in the opposite direction? This already exists, I think. I mean, how many adults hang in the chans? How many even know which are the good ones? And then there's the whole coded-slang aspect. Sadly enough, adults you find there are mainly perverts, cops, and extremists trolling for fresh meat.
- fwip 7y agoMore than you'd think