8 ms·
> A nuclear fission world will never happen due to the economics of it. I'm not sure why this keeps being said. France's prices for electricity are cheaper tha
by godelski 7y ago
> A nuclear fission world will never happen due to the economics of it.
I'm not sure why this keeps being said. France's prices for electricity are cheaper than Germany. In fact they are cheaper than most European countries [0]. Nuclear does have a lot of upfront costs, but they are cheap to run once built. But the construction price will never drop if we stop building. Doing so has already made prices go up.
What really matters is 1) can the company that made the plant make a profit? 2) If we need to subsidize to make 1=yes then is that price cheaper than the cost of not doing it (cost by economic damage done by increased CO2 during that period).
But the irony of this is that your argument is very similar to that which many have made about solar.
I expect the same thing will happen when fusion becomes a thing. In reality it is all about the S curve.
[0] https://1-stromvergleich.com/electricity-prices-europe/ https://1-stromvergleich.com/electricity-prices-europe/
- epistasis 7y agoYour link is about residential prices, not about the cost to build the reactors. There are two key questions: 1) what was the subsidy level for construction of the French generation of reactors, and 2) can we do this again? That second question is of course the most important one, and the answer seems to be a resounding and hard no, at least if the French are constructing it, based on their recent attempts. South Korea is also cited as another country that may have figured out how to build reactors cheaply. However recent news is that it was all cartels and corruption and there's likely massive amounts of fraud. That leaves what, Canada and Russia? Canada I kind of trust, and Russia not at all. CANDUs were pretty great, but we can't exactly order more of them now. It seems that the age of the Rankine cycle's efficiency is coming to an end, at least in terms of cost effectiveness. Even natural gas uses a combined cycle to compete these days, as new tech finally usurps what has been the champion for over a century.
- pfdietz 7y agoCanada gave up on CANDU. The ACR got no buyers, and the remnants of AECL were sold for a mere $15M.
- gridlockd 7y ago> I'm not sure why this keeps being said. Because there is a "real cost" to running a nuclear plant that can be arbitrarily inflated. If you factor in stuff like "one major disaster every twenty years" or "waste storage for 10,000 years", of course the calculation is different than if you assume "no disasters" and "we'll deal with it later". It also very much depends on the regulatory environment that these reactors are built in. Perhaps forty years ago it would've been possible to build reactors economically in the US, but after Chernobyl/Fukushima any new reactor would likely face far more intense scrutiny.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoQuestions I really have never gotten an answer I find satisfactory with regards to nuclear. What's the long term storage costs for spent fuel rods? Is this factored into the price? Is post plant cleanup factored into generation costs (we're paying for a nuclear plant closing nearby in our electric bills now on top of generation costs)? Can we possibly reuse those spent fuel rods for something else useful? Can we prevent disasters like Fukishima? Can we prevent every single disaster? Thorium reactors aren't currently economically viable. Molten salt reactors come with their own downsides but are safer from what I understand, but honestly can't say for sure. Fusion reactors would be base case scenario as far as I understand but aren't currently viable. We already had one problem by not thinking about long term negatives, I don't want to replace one problem for another, far bigger, far longer term problem. Nuclear problems tend to last longer than carbon problems, disasters like Chernobyl will cost money for literally generations even with it's new cap as it will be constantly needing to be replaced. Solar has it's own problems with messy pollution on creation, wind seems cleanest long term, storage for renewables will probably end up being some type of multi-lake hydro as the "battery" in places where it's viable. Maybe underground aquifers where evaporation is an issue? I'm all for nuclear in places that already have radiation issues, i.e. space, moon. But I really want to avoid contamination of the only planet we can currently live in as a species.
- godelski 7y agoI'll do my best to answer. I've worked on rad shielding, but that is a different side. If acidburnNSA (a reactor scientist) shows up, ask him, he frequents nuclear posts. These will be basic answers so I hope they help and I'll expand on them if you want to follow up, but there's a lot to cover just in the first paragraph. > What's the long term storage costs for spent fuel rods? Not too much. Frankly because the quantity is low. This is one of the things people don't realize, while the waste is highly contaminated there's REALLY small quantities. We're talking about less than a coke can of waste per person per year. (that's not per reactor, that's ALL reactors) It is expensive though. The cost of nuclear is from construction and decommissioning. Operating costs are extremely low. > Is this factored into the price? Yes (mostly) > Is post plant cleanup factored into generation costs (we're paying for a nuclear plant closing nearby in our electric bills now on top of generation costs)? Yes (mostly) Mostly means that it is supposed to be factored in. But those are of course estimates. I'll also be honest that sometimes people cheat. > Can we possibly reuse those spent fuel rods for something else useful? They already are. 17% of France's electricity is from recycled nuclear. That's not 17% of France's nuclear energy, that's 17% of TOTAL energy. Additionally most of these materials are used for a lot of other things. A lot goes to medical. > Can we prevent disasters like Fukishima? Yes, actually Fukushima is a great example of how to prevent disasters like Fukushima. The reactors that didn't fail had their backup generators on higher ground. There were also better safety factors and I'm over simplifying things, but the reactors that failed had sub par safety factors. We've had much better designed reactors for awhile, but that's a longer conversation and extremely convoluted (you'll commonly see it expressed simpler, but nothing is simple). > Can we prevent every single disaster? No. Such a notion is really unrealistic. I'd rephrase it as "Can we reduce danger to an acceptable risk?" Which I'd say the answer is yes. I'd even say we've been there for awhile. Nuclear fission is, next to hydro, the safest form of electricity we have, even when you include predictions of future deaths from past events (Chernobyl and Fukushima). > (an implied one) Can we reduce environmental damage from meltdown events? Yes! Actually this is super interesting. Chernobyl has turned into a really big nature preserve. Wildlife is thriving there. It is interesting to also look at radiation maps of Japan [0]. For context to this map, all measurements are in nSv (1e-9Sv). 1Sv within a year equates to a 5.5% increase in chance of cancer over your lifetime. But 20mSv is the max allowed dosage to a radiation worker. You'll notice that the vast majority of places is WELL below the 20mSv mark. Max value I found was 8,528nSv/hr (82528nSv/hr1e-9(Sv/nSv)24(hrs)*365(days) = 74.7mSv/yr). The point of this last part isn't to say something like "oh well humans can live here hur dur dur", but rather to illustrate why Fukushima is turning into a nature preserve. But I do also want to acknowledge that many people did lose their homes and have been permanently displaced. Again, I believe that we should be honest. > Thorium reactors... This is a convoluted subject. I'll leave it for another post. There's (a lot of) potential but we definitely need to do more research and testing. > Fusion reactors... Are a completely different beast. They don't have the same radiation concerns. Their waste product is mostly Helium (a resource we are in short supply of). While fission and fusion are both nuclear based there are more differences than similarities (including power output, by orders of magnitude). Think like the difference between nuclear and coal. Both heat water to turn turbines (this is how almost all electricity is generated actually), but they're very different in most aspects. > We already had one problem by not thinking about long term negatives... Honestly this is why I'm PRO nuclear. Sure it has negatives, and I'm not going to try to deny them. If we're considering human lives then consider that coal kills an order of magnitude more Americans per year than have ever died from Chernobyl (several orders when you consider the world). We also have to consider the places that have become uninhabitable because of mining and other things that humans have done. Everything has negatives, I think we're just more aware of nuclear's (fission's). It is about the exchange of good and bad and if we net more good than bad. It is also about comparing to our other options. (If we're in a negative sum game we are trying to get the least negative, but we're still getting negative utility) I won't dive into this because it seems you're aware of this. It is honestly complicated and a difficult subject. It takes a lot of research. But there's a saying "When it comes to nuclear, those that know the most fear the least." There's a reason that the majority of climate researchers are pro nuclear, there's a reason the UN Climate Committee endorses nuclear. > I really want to avoid contamination of the only planet we can currently live in as a species. I'm with you there. 110%. We're hundreds of years from being able to live somewhere else. We must do everything we can to protect THIS planet. Again, I'm happy for a follow up and I will do my best to answer. [0] https://jciv.iidj.net/map/ https://jciv.iidj.net/map/
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoIf France ever experiences a baf nuclear event, that nuclear power won't feel very cheap.
- godelski 7y agoWhat is the point of this comment? It is very loaded. Are you talking about fear? Because all evidence shows that nuclear is the safest next to hydro power (yes, even more than solar). Like I just don't know how to interpret your point.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ygra 7y agoI guess the point was that externalities like those risks (however small) are not part of the price customers pay. Instead those are footed by the taxpayer when something happens. That likely distorts the real cost of hydro-electric and coal as well.
- godelski 7y agoThat's what insurance is for [0][1]. Pay attention to the numbers. The second link is more detailed. [0] https://www.iii.org/article/insurance-coverage-nuclear-accidents https://www.iii.org/article/insurance-coverage-nuclear-accid... [1] https://www.naic.org/cipr_topics/topic_nuclear_liability_insurance.htm https://www.naic.org/cipr_topics/topic_nuclear_liability_ins...
- the_why_of_y 7y agoSo a nuclear accident in the US is only insured up to ~$13 billion? The numbers I can find on the cost of the Fukushima Daiichi accident are higher than that (and I wonder how reliable they are): https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/08/opinion/playing-pass-the-parcel-with-fukushima.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/08/opinion/playing-pass-the-... Japan’s leaders hope to restore for human habitation more than 100 cities, towns and villages scattered over hundreds of square miles. The government has allocated more than $15 billion for this work. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/jan/31/possible-nuclear-fuel-find-fukushima-plant https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/jan/31/possible... In December, the government said the estimated cost of decommissioning the plant and decontaminating the surrounding area, as well as paying compensation and storing radioactive waste, had risen to 21.5 trillion yen ($187bn), nearly double an estimate released in 2013. (Interestingly, Wikipedia claims that the insurance policies that applied to Fukushima Daiichi specifically excluded accidents caused by earthquake/tsumani.) Of course, with insufficient insurance coverage, when faced with a major accident the company owning the plant will just declare bankruptcy and leave the tax payer to pay for the mess. So we have another case of "privatize the profits, socialize the losses", which IMHO is one of the biggest problems with nuclear energy, and is effectively a subsidy that keeps the price artificially low.
- benj111 7y agoHinckley Point C in the UK has a contract for £92.50MWH [1]. Given that some other operators have pulled out suggests that isn't overly high, but as wind is currently getting priced in the mid £50s then yes it is expensive. Further, nuclear isn't a particularly good match for renewables because it isn't as dispatchable as other options. [1] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/hinkley-nuclear-plant-edf-uk-households-energy-power-somerset-government-a7849216.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/hinkley-nuc...
- godelski 7y ago> Further, nuclear isn't a particularly good match for renewables because it isn't as dispatchable as other options. I do want to remind you: no one that is pro-nuclear is anti-renewable. I'd say that if they are pro-nuclear they are very likely pro-renewable. The thing though is that you're drastically over simplifying the energy problem. Battery technology just isn't there yet (they just have nowhere near the energy density, even the most advanced batteries are dwarfed by the energy density of basic fossil fuels[0]). Until then we have to face the duck curve. So what are our choices? Natural gas, coal, nuclear. Take your pick. We need energy sources that can be throttled up and down and can produce continual amounts of energy. Renewable just can't do this without batteries, and batteries aren't there. So it isn't that we don't want renewables, it is that we have picked nuclear vs fossil fuels. [0] https://www.extremetech.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/EnergyDensity.jpg https://www.extremetech.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/Energ...
- benj111 7y agoHey, I wouldn't put myself in the Anti nuclear camp. Its just the costs, they're high and increasing. My point about nuclear not being dispatchable is that if wind is going to be the cheap backbone, then any expensive generation has to find a niche that works around that. Nuclear doesn't have that niche. I seem to be taking a longer view than you, maybe in the 20 - 30 year time frame you're right. But in that sort of time frame is it even worth trying to start building a new nuclear power station? Where after all the politicking you've spent 10 years before you've even broken ground.