3 ms·
Being tutored one-on-one by someone with enough education to be a college professor is about the most intense education a youth can get. It's vastly more intens
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Being tutored one-on-one by someone with enough education to be a college professor is about the most intense education a youth can get. It's vastly more intense than the same time spent in a class of twenty or thirty students.
- scarface74 7y agoThat’s exactly what I’m saying - that he had a better outcome not because of any innate capabilities but because he had parents who could afford to give him that advantage. And I had the most “intense” help you could have - a parent who had all of the know how and resources to ensure her child did well in school and on the SAT. How many kids struggling in Calculus or Trig can get as much help at home as they could possibly need. Did I mention that I had an aunt that taught science at my school and that one of my math teachers were taught by my mom?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYour comments are all over the place, from asserting that "money and connections open doors"* and some people do test prep and get no better to bragging you got the best help from unpaid relatives who knew their stuff. I have no idea what point you are trying to make. There seems to be zero consistency to your various remarks. * https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20012049 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20012049
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jnbiche 7y agoHe's been extremely consistent in his remarks: privilege and wealth result in higher test scores for environmental reasons. I'm undecided as to whether or not I agree, but she/he's been very consistent in their stance. Also, accusing someone of "bragging" when they're providing anecdotal evidence for their point of view assumes bad faith where there may be none.
- scarface74 7y agoSo I said: I didn’t have to go get help before school from an overworked teacher who volunteered to help kids, but I could get all the help I needed at home? And I know plenty of people who took the test more than once, got help by going to “SAT prep” classes before school etc. and didn’t get any better. The difference being that while SAT prep was offered by overworked teachers who volunteered to help a class full of students before school started, that was a lot different than having one on one help with a college professor. Also, even the kids who could get help before school were fortunate enough to get a ride to school. Some students couldn’t make it before school because their bus came too late and their parent(s) couldn’t take them because they had to be at work. Have you ever thought about instead of just lashing out you could ask for clarification when you don’t get the point - that others actually did get? And how is it “bragging” to say that I had relatives who were teachers and I did very well in what I admitted was one of the poorest cities in the country? In fact, growing up in the segregated south as my relatives did, one of the few and ways to guarantee a middle class job was to go into education. My relatives were among the first to actually be able to teach in an integrated school - we aren’t talking about a lot of “privilege” here.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm not lashing out. Characterizing my remark that way is a personal attack. I stated that I have no idea what your point is and explained why I'm confused. I consider it bragging because you say that your stepson was simply fortunate ("privileged") to have someone able to pay for it, talk about doing well yourself without monied solutions and also state that it is your stepson, so, no, he didn't inherit your IQ. At every turn, it paints you as the only person with some kind of virtue, whether smarts or money to spend, and dismisses the idea that it genuinely makes other people "smarter," denying them a claim to virtue. I think the overall picture painted here is one where you see yourself as innately smart but your stepson as just lucky his mom married a rich man who could "open doors" with his money. I still don't really get what your point is. Your remarks strike me as very inconsistent. But, in the grand scheme of things, it isn't at all important that I get your point. I'm just a stranger on the internet.
- 7y ago