3 ms·
Why do you think that it's likely that someone in Intel design meetings had thought of that if literally noone outside Intel did for many years? It obviously w
by PeterisP 7y ago
Why do you think that it's likely that someone in Intel design meetings had thought of that if literally noone outside Intel did for many years?
It obviously wasn't obvious to the very, very many people worldwide who know about execution-time attacks and other sidechannel leakage, as it took more than 10 years of almost every chip worldwide being vulnerable until it was noticed. It's not as if some 2016 design tradeoff suddenly enabled Meltdown. Engineers were carefully studying competitor's chip designs, and none of them noticed that flaw for more than a decade.
- viraptor 7y agoEven better: at least one person documented thinking about this issue, trying to exploit it and failing - showing that even if you could come up with this, it was really non trivial to achieve.
- throwaway2048 7y agoThis is a really weak argument because plenty of hilariously stupid and easy to exploit bugs are found in extremely widely used software all the time.