5 ms·
...people who aren't in that top tier have seen their real wages fall consistently since the 1980s. This claim doesn't pass the smell test. Can you name a sing
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
...people who aren't in that top tier have seen their real wages fall consistently since the 1980s.
This claim doesn't pass the smell test. Can you name a single good or service (note: not a category of goods/services) which is less available today than it was in the 80's? If not, then real wages (i.e., wages measured in terms of the amount of stuff they can buy) have not gone down.
- jbooth 16y agoI know you know the definition of real wages, and it's nothing to do with what you said -- it's wages indexed by BLS inflation numbers. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:United_States_Income_Distribution_1967-2003.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:United_States_Income_Distr... I overspoke. They've stagnated for the bottom 4 quintiles since the early 80s, and declined since 2000. For future trends, I'd extrapolate from the current U-3 and more importantly U-6 figures (they don't look good).
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIn general, the definition of economic concepts does not include references to specific government agencies. Are "real wages" not a meaningful concept in Mexico, beyond the reach of the BLS? If you look at the definition of inflation (keep track of units!), you can immediately see that wages indexed by inflation == amount of stuff you can buy. As for BLS inflation numbers, I agree that by that specific measurement, real wages appear to have stagnated. On the other hand, people today have more stuff than they did in the 80's. That suggests the BLS inflation numbers might not mean what you think they mean. (It's actually pretty clear why they don't quite match up if you look closely at the methodology of the BLS. The basket of goods used to compute inflation today is larger than the basket of goods in 1980. A proper measure of inflation would take a fixed basket of goods at t[0] and measure the cost of the same basket of goods at t[1]. But that would require different inflation measures based on the starting year. This would be too complicated to give to politicians, so the BLS doesn't bother. )
- jbooth 16y agoOk, so let's throw out the BLS inflation numbers even though they're the standard for basically everyone in academia and industry because you don't like what they say in this case? What's the alternative? I wasn't talking about Mexico, I'd defer to the canonical inflation figure for there if I were. If you want to kibbitz about the basket of goods, fine.. but that conversation's gonna go right to "fix our egregiously broken healthcare system".
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe BLS numbers are not as good as you seem to think, and many people are aware of their flaws. For example, the Boskin Commission (in 1996) concluded that inflation was overstated by about 1.3%/year (up to 1996, which includes about 16 years of the period you are interested in). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boskin_Commission http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boskin_Commission Regardless of your argumentum ad populum, do you disagree with my claim that a correct measure of inflation should not use an expanding basket of goods? If so, please explain why we should care about this quantity: BLS-adjusted wage = (nominal wage) x (cost of smaller basket A in 1980) / (cost of bigger basket B in 2010)
- jbooth 16y agoSo did you cancel your subscription to the Economist and the WSJ? Because they cite the BLS inflation numbers all the time, like multiple times per week.
- lotharbot 16y agoBLS inflation numbers get cited all the time. That doesn't mean they actually show what [random pundit X] thinks they show. In particular, they don't support the claim that people have less purchasing power now than they did 30 years ago. They don't directly measure purchasing power; "real wages" is a misnomer, and a decrease in "real wages" doesn't necessarily correspond to "starving" the consumers as you claimed in an ancestor post. When asked to directly measure purchasing power, why do you instead go for the "appeal to authority" regarding an indirect and clearly flawed method? Why not try to actually directly answer the question at hand: name one good or service that is less available now than it was 20-30 years ago, thereby establishing an actual decrease in purchasing power for the consumers you claim are being "starved".
- Symmetry 16y agoBut its not too far from being true, wages have increased very slowly vs. GDP. What _has_ risen at the same rate as the GDP is the amount spent on employee compensation, but that includes wages, benefits, and the costs of administering the first two. A lot of this is rising health-care costs that have been increasingly been met by employer provided health insurance, but part of it is just companies preferring to give compensation in ways that won't be taxed.
- hackinthebochs 16y agoI think the point that jbooth is trying to make is that, the wealth of the country has measurably increased since the 1980's but that increase is going mostly to the wealthy. The problem is jbooth is trying to prove this using inflation data. Indexing purchasing power to a constant basket of goods is missing the point because our production has become more efficient over that time. But this is exactly the point he's trying to make: While productivity has increased across the board, the wealthy are gaining disproportionately from that increase in productivity. I think this is indisputable. The middle class is shrinking precisely because what it means to be "middle class" should reasonably grow with increases in productivity. However, this isn't happening. And by many measures its decreasing (say health care, college education). The question should be then: is it in societies interest to make sure that the benefits of increased productivity are distributed more proportionally, and should government attempt to accomplish this.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe middle class is shrinking precisely because what it means to be "middle class" should reasonably grow with increases in productivity. And it has. Every decile has considerably more stuff today than they did in 1980. More cars, bigger houses, more food, more medicine, and more education [1]. Jbooth is making the fallacy of measuring income in non-constant baskets of goods. His claim is that in 1980, median wages bought you 1 basket of goods, and in 2010, median wages still buys only 1 basket of goods. He is deliberately ignoring the fact that the basket in 2010 is bigger. However, this isn't happening. And by many measures its decreasing (say health care, college education). College consumption has increased: http://www.childstats.gov/americaschildren/edu6.asp http://www.childstats.gov/americaschildren/edu6.asp The same is true of medicine - we consume more drugs, visit the doctor more, and get more treatments. According to a quick google search, the % of the labor force producing health care has gone up considerably: http://www.doctorhousingbubble.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/chart-10-healtcare-employment.png http://www.doctorhousingbubble.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/1... You might want to argue that consumption should have increased more, but it's nonsensical to argue that consumption has not increased significantly (as jbooth is). [1] I don't like treating education as a consumption good, since it's primarily purpose is to gain credentials/skills so you can get a job.