3 ms·
> Why is there so little investment in clean energy innovation? Because the expected value of ROI is not strong.
by paulddraper 7y ago
> Why is there so little investment in clean energy innovation?
Because the expected value of ROI is not strong.
- HaukeHi 7y agoOf course, that's ultimately it. I was just attempting to explain why this is and why there is a market failure. Because carbon externalities are not fully internalized.
- ThomPete 7y agoThe problem though is inherent in clean energy forms given that most of them are not really going to provide us with anything even close go the energy density and dual use as especially oil(ex plastic) but also to some extent coal an nuclear. I have been trying to find things to invest in in this area and its not really positive what Ive realized. We made most of the big discoveries and breakthroughs with fossil fuels and nuclear and there just isnt that many other opportunities out there to do anything with the density of ex coal which makes it hard to compete with since both ex sun and wind would need backup of either coal or nuclear which at the moments isnt factored into the price of sun and wind. Fuell cells is also far far away for now which leaves fusion but that require ex magnetic force that can contain plasma. In other words at the end of the day if we want to continue to live modern lives with all its benefits, if we want other countries to improve their lives too, its time to be honest and realize that fossil fuels and nuclear is going to be our primary source of energy for a long long time. I would love to be proven wrong and would invest right away but i fear we will have to accept whatever the climate will throw at us and adopt as we have for thousands of years.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoNuclear is clean energy, so more nuclear and less fossil fuel is already a win. Investments are needed here, though I can't say whether they're good from investor's POV.
- ThomPete 7y agoYeah but nuclear isnt politically in vogue
- TeMPOraL 7y agoMoney can move politics. Also, while large plants are definitely not popular right now, small reactors just might. There's been some work done in miniaturizing nuclear reactors; it may be worth looking into.
- petre 7y agoNuclear reactors are already miniaturized. That's what we use on nuclear powered ships and subs. They're also safer than utility scale. SMRs can be mass produced under strict QA, transported and assembled on site and offer important safety guarantees. https://www.nuscalepower.com/benefits https://www.nuscalepower.com/benefits
- paulddraper 7y ago> Nuclear is clean energy Except the biggest problems with nuclear has to do with extremely hazardous materials.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThis is quite literally a non-problem. Next-gen plants will happily burn this waste, but even without them, I don't think you realize how little of that waste is generated per gigawatt hour - on the order of 150 grams. It's dangerous, sure (just like a lot of other chemical waste we produce on industrial scale), but we know how to store it well, and there's so little of it. If you reprocess the waste (take out the parts that can be used again as fuel), you end up with a nasty chemical sludge with half-life on the order of only 40 years, which is not that much. Storing that waste over centuries is a difficult problem, but is a really nice problem to have compared to making the planet uninhabitable and/or shutting down civilization.